CB-WP-0042 T01-T04: H2's scoped stress, with the named defects caught
Some checks failed
ci / check (push) Failing after 4s

H2 is ground-game's answer to our H1 reading — that a flat +1 to every
seat is a solve-rate tax scaling with the number of Problems. Unclaimed
Problems now tick only the seats in scope: global (all), personal (the
owner), bond (the owner's Bond network over Bond edges only, degree 0
falling back to personal), assigned by hidden priority so 2p never has the
bond card in play.

T01: the package is vendored with digests, and H2's Problems.csv is r0's
with one column added and NOTHING else changed — checked, not assumed,
because the delta claims deal_and_thresholds unchanged and a silent
difference would make every H2-vs-baseline comparison a comparison of two
boards as well as two rule sets. Scopes are read from the column, not
derived from the priority in Rust: F25 exists because we hardcoded numbers
the edition already carried.

T02: owner and scope are new ProblemState fields, both Option and both
skipped when None, so a baseline state serialises without them and every
recorded scenario's hash is untouched — asserted on the JSON, not assumed.
with_variant() replaces the bare field write, because state.variant = v
would leave owners unassigned: a silently wrong game rather than a failing
one.

T03: every named defect is mutation-proven — traversing Rivalry edges,
applying stacking once, a degree-0 owner ticking everyone, personal
hitting everyone. The degree-0 mutation MISSED first: the fallback lives
inside bond_network and the mutation broke the None-owner arm instead, a
different branch. It stayed green until aimed at the path the test
exercises. A mutation that misses is not evidence the test works.

T04: ownership is not a permission. Filtering SOLVE to the owner turns it
red, which is the regression this task exists for — the engine had no
owner concept before T02 added one.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
This commit is contained in:
tegwick 2026-08-08 16:06:21 +02:00
parent 05d1a9aada
commit 04e26b3077
9 changed files with 900 additions and 7 deletions

View file

@ -0,0 +1,21 @@
problem_id,scenario_id,visibility,stress_scope,hidden_priority,title,problem_text,required_solution,symbol_id,point_value,front_rules,reveal_effect,unresolved_effect,back_design_id
PRB_01_S,SCN_01,Surface,global,0,Deadline Missed,A promised result was not delivered when expected.,Repair,SYM_REPAIR,2,Resolve with Repair. Value: 2.,None in the core set.,"H2: while unclaimed, +1 Stress at Round End to stress_scope=global (personal=owner; bond=owner's Bond network; global=all).",BACK_PROBLEM_SURFACE
PRB_01_1,SCN_01,Hidden,personal,1,Unclear Ownership,Responsibility for the commitment and the work was never made explicit.,Clarify,SYM_CLARIFY,2,Resolve with Clarify. Value: 2.,None in the core set.,"H2: while unclaimed, +1 Stress at Round End to stress_scope=personal (personal=owner; bond=owner's Bond network; global=all).",BACK_PROBLEM
PRB_01_2,SCN_01,Hidden,personal,2,Unspoken Overload,The work required more capacity than someone could safely or fairly provide.,Boundary,SYM_BOUNDARY,2,Resolve with Boundary. Value: 2.,None in the core set.,"H2: while unclaimed, +1 Stress at Round End to stress_scope=personal (personal=owner; bond=owner's Bond network; global=all).",BACK_PROBLEM
PRB_01_3,SCN_01,Hidden,bond,3,Bad News Was Delayed,A warning was withheld until the remaining options became worse.,Repair,SYM_REPAIR,3,Resolve with Repair. Value: 3.,None in the core set.,"H2: while unclaimed, +1 Stress at Round End to stress_scope=bond (personal=owner; bond=owner's Bond network; global=all).",BACK_PROBLEM
PRB_01_4,SCN_01,Hidden,personal,4,No Checkpoint Process,The group had no reliable moment for testing progress and changing course.,Change,SYM_CHANGE,3,Resolve with Change. Value: 3.,None in the core set.,"H2: while unclaimed, +1 Stress at Round End to stress_scope=personal (personal=owner; bond=owner's Bond network; global=all).",BACK_PROBLEM
PRB_02_S,SCN_02,Surface,global,0,Shared Task Left Undone,"A recurring responsibility was not completed, and others absorbed the impact.",Repair,SYM_REPAIR,2,Resolve with Repair. Value: 2.,None in the core set.,"H2: while unclaimed, +1 Stress at Round End to stress_scope=global (personal=owner; bond=owner's Bond network; global=all).",BACK_PROBLEM_SURFACE
PRB_02_1,SCN_02,Hidden,personal,1,Different Standards,"Players were using different definitions of complete, timely, or fair.",Clarify,SYM_CLARIFY,2,Resolve with Clarify. Value: 2.,None in the core set.,"H2: while unclaimed, +1 Stress at Round End to stress_scope=personal (personal=owner; bond=owner's Bond network; global=all).",BACK_PROBLEM
PRB_02_2,SCN_02,Hidden,personal,2,Invisible Workload,Some contributions and constraints were not visible to the group.,Boundary,SYM_BOUNDARY,2,Resolve with Boundary. Value: 2.,None in the core set.,"H2: while unclaimed, +1 Stress at Round End to stress_scope=personal (personal=owner; bond=owner's Bond network; global=all).",BACK_PROBLEM
PRB_02_3,SCN_02,Hidden,bond,3,Resentment Never Raised,Frustration accumulated without a direct request or acknowledgement.,Repair,SYM_REPAIR,3,Resolve with Repair. Value: 3.,None in the core set.,"H2: while unclaimed, +1 Stress at Round End to stress_scope=bond (personal=owner; bond=owner's Bond network; global=all).",BACK_PROBLEM
PRB_02_4,SCN_02,Hidden,personal,4,No Ownership Routine,The group relied on goodwill instead of a dependable allocation method.,Change,SYM_CHANGE,3,Resolve with Change. Value: 3.,None in the core set.,"H2: while unclaimed, +1 Stress at Round End to stress_scope=personal (personal=owner; bond=owner's Bond network; global=all).",BACK_PROBLEM
PRB_03_S,SCN_03,Surface,global,0,Decision Announced as Settled,A group-affecting choice was presented as final before meaningful agreement.,Boundary,SYM_BOUNDARY,2,Resolve with Boundary. Value: 2.,None in the core set.,"H2: while unclaimed, +1 Stress at Round End to stress_scope=global (personal=owner; bond=owner's Bond network; global=all).",BACK_PROBLEM_SURFACE
PRB_03_1,SCN_03,Hidden,personal,1,Mandate Was Ambiguous,"It was unclear who could decide, advise, consent, or veto.",Clarify,SYM_CLARIFY,2,Resolve with Clarify. Value: 2.,None in the core set.,"H2: while unclaimed, +1 Stress at Round End to stress_scope=personal (personal=owner; bond=owner's Bond network; global=all).",BACK_PROBLEM
PRB_03_2,SCN_03,Hidden,personal,2,Contributions Were Dismissed,Relevant input was ignored or treated as less legitimate.,Repair,SYM_REPAIR,2,Resolve with Repair. Value: 2.,None in the core set.,"H2: while unclaimed, +1 Stress at Round End to stress_scope=personal (personal=owner; bond=owner's Bond network; global=all).",BACK_PROBLEM
PRB_03_3,SCN_03,Hidden,bond,3,One Voice Spoke for Others,A player claimed authority to represent people who had not agreed.,Boundary,SYM_BOUNDARY,3,Resolve with Boundary. Value: 3.,None in the core set.,"H2: while unclaimed, +1 Stress at Round End to stress_scope=bond (personal=owner; bond=owner's Bond network; global=all).",BACK_PROBLEM
PRB_03_4,SCN_03,Hidden,personal,4,No Decision Rule,The group had no shared method for turning discussion into a legitimate choice.,Change,SYM_CHANGE,3,Resolve with Change. Value: 3.,None in the core set.,"H2: while unclaimed, +1 Stress at Round End to stress_scope=personal (personal=owner; bond=owner's Bond network; global=all).",BACK_PROBLEM
PRB_04_S,SCN_04,Surface,global,0,Private Information Spread,Information moved beyond the circle in which it was originally shared.,Repair,SYM_REPAIR,2,Resolve with Repair. Value: 2.,None in the core set.,"H2: while unclaimed, +1 Stress at Round End to stress_scope=global (personal=owner; bond=owner's Bond network; global=all).",BACK_PROBLEM_SURFACE
PRB_04_1,SCN_04,Hidden,personal,1,Confidentiality Was Assumed,The players never made the scope of confidentiality explicit.,Clarify,SYM_CLARIFY,2,Resolve with Clarify. Value: 2.,None in the core set.,"H2: while unclaimed, +1 Stress at Round End to stress_scope=personal (personal=owner; bond=owner's Bond network; global=all).",BACK_PROBLEM
PRB_04_2,SCN_04,Hidden,personal,2,Exposure Caused Harm,"The sharing changed another player's safety, reputation, or freedom to choose.",Repair,SYM_REPAIR,2,Resolve with Repair. Value: 2.,None in the core set.,"H2: while unclaimed, +1 Stress at Round End to stress_scope=personal (personal=owner; bond=owner's Bond network; global=all).",BACK_PROBLEM
PRB_04_3,SCN_04,Hidden,bond,3,Consent Boundary Was Ignored,A clear or reasonably expected limit on sharing was crossed.,Boundary,SYM_BOUNDARY,3,Resolve with Boundary. Value: 3.,None in the core set.,"H2: while unclaimed, +1 Stress at Round End to stress_scope=bond (personal=owner; bond=owner's Bond network; global=all).",BACK_PROBLEM
PRB_04_4,SCN_04,Hidden,personal,4,No Sharing Protocol,"The group lacked a repeatable rule for consent, need-to-know, and escalation.",Change,SYM_CHANGE,3,Resolve with Change. Value: 3.,None in the core set.,"H2: while unclaimed, +1 Stress at Round End to stress_scope=personal (personal=owner; bond=owner's Bond network; global=all).",BACK_PROBLEM
1 problem_id scenario_id visibility stress_scope hidden_priority title problem_text required_solution symbol_id point_value front_rules reveal_effect unresolved_effect back_design_id
2 PRB_01_S SCN_01 Surface global 0 Deadline Missed A promised result was not delivered when expected. Repair SYM_REPAIR 2 Resolve with Repair. Value: 2. None in the core set. H2: while unclaimed, +1 Stress at Round End to stress_scope=global (personal=owner; bond=owner's Bond network; global=all). BACK_PROBLEM_SURFACE
3 PRB_01_1 SCN_01 Hidden personal 1 Unclear Ownership Responsibility for the commitment and the work was never made explicit. Clarify SYM_CLARIFY 2 Resolve with Clarify. Value: 2. None in the core set. H2: while unclaimed, +1 Stress at Round End to stress_scope=personal (personal=owner; bond=owner's Bond network; global=all). BACK_PROBLEM
4 PRB_01_2 SCN_01 Hidden personal 2 Unspoken Overload The work required more capacity than someone could safely or fairly provide. Boundary SYM_BOUNDARY 2 Resolve with Boundary. Value: 2. None in the core set. H2: while unclaimed, +1 Stress at Round End to stress_scope=personal (personal=owner; bond=owner's Bond network; global=all). BACK_PROBLEM
5 PRB_01_3 SCN_01 Hidden bond 3 Bad News Was Delayed A warning was withheld until the remaining options became worse. Repair SYM_REPAIR 3 Resolve with Repair. Value: 3. None in the core set. H2: while unclaimed, +1 Stress at Round End to stress_scope=bond (personal=owner; bond=owner's Bond network; global=all). BACK_PROBLEM
6 PRB_01_4 SCN_01 Hidden personal 4 No Checkpoint Process The group had no reliable moment for testing progress and changing course. Change SYM_CHANGE 3 Resolve with Change. Value: 3. None in the core set. H2: while unclaimed, +1 Stress at Round End to stress_scope=personal (personal=owner; bond=owner's Bond network; global=all). BACK_PROBLEM
7 PRB_02_S SCN_02 Surface global 0 Shared Task Left Undone A recurring responsibility was not completed, and others absorbed the impact. Repair SYM_REPAIR 2 Resolve with Repair. Value: 2. None in the core set. H2: while unclaimed, +1 Stress at Round End to stress_scope=global (personal=owner; bond=owner's Bond network; global=all). BACK_PROBLEM_SURFACE
8 PRB_02_1 SCN_02 Hidden personal 1 Different Standards Players were using different definitions of complete, timely, or fair. Clarify SYM_CLARIFY 2 Resolve with Clarify. Value: 2. None in the core set. H2: while unclaimed, +1 Stress at Round End to stress_scope=personal (personal=owner; bond=owner's Bond network; global=all). BACK_PROBLEM
9 PRB_02_2 SCN_02 Hidden personal 2 Invisible Workload Some contributions and constraints were not visible to the group. Boundary SYM_BOUNDARY 2 Resolve with Boundary. Value: 2. None in the core set. H2: while unclaimed, +1 Stress at Round End to stress_scope=personal (personal=owner; bond=owner's Bond network; global=all). BACK_PROBLEM
10 PRB_02_3 SCN_02 Hidden bond 3 Resentment Never Raised Frustration accumulated without a direct request or acknowledgement. Repair SYM_REPAIR 3 Resolve with Repair. Value: 3. None in the core set. H2: while unclaimed, +1 Stress at Round End to stress_scope=bond (personal=owner; bond=owner's Bond network; global=all). BACK_PROBLEM
11 PRB_02_4 SCN_02 Hidden personal 4 No Ownership Routine The group relied on goodwill instead of a dependable allocation method. Change SYM_CHANGE 3 Resolve with Change. Value: 3. None in the core set. H2: while unclaimed, +1 Stress at Round End to stress_scope=personal (personal=owner; bond=owner's Bond network; global=all). BACK_PROBLEM
12 PRB_03_S SCN_03 Surface global 0 Decision Announced as Settled A group-affecting choice was presented as final before meaningful agreement. Boundary SYM_BOUNDARY 2 Resolve with Boundary. Value: 2. None in the core set. H2: while unclaimed, +1 Stress at Round End to stress_scope=global (personal=owner; bond=owner's Bond network; global=all). BACK_PROBLEM_SURFACE
13 PRB_03_1 SCN_03 Hidden personal 1 Mandate Was Ambiguous It was unclear who could decide, advise, consent, or veto. Clarify SYM_CLARIFY 2 Resolve with Clarify. Value: 2. None in the core set. H2: while unclaimed, +1 Stress at Round End to stress_scope=personal (personal=owner; bond=owner's Bond network; global=all). BACK_PROBLEM
14 PRB_03_2 SCN_03 Hidden personal 2 Contributions Were Dismissed Relevant input was ignored or treated as less legitimate. Repair SYM_REPAIR 2 Resolve with Repair. Value: 2. None in the core set. H2: while unclaimed, +1 Stress at Round End to stress_scope=personal (personal=owner; bond=owner's Bond network; global=all). BACK_PROBLEM
15 PRB_03_3 SCN_03 Hidden bond 3 One Voice Spoke for Others A player claimed authority to represent people who had not agreed. Boundary SYM_BOUNDARY 3 Resolve with Boundary. Value: 3. None in the core set. H2: while unclaimed, +1 Stress at Round End to stress_scope=bond (personal=owner; bond=owner's Bond network; global=all). BACK_PROBLEM
16 PRB_03_4 SCN_03 Hidden personal 4 No Decision Rule The group had no shared method for turning discussion into a legitimate choice. Change SYM_CHANGE 3 Resolve with Change. Value: 3. None in the core set. H2: while unclaimed, +1 Stress at Round End to stress_scope=personal (personal=owner; bond=owner's Bond network; global=all). BACK_PROBLEM
17 PRB_04_S SCN_04 Surface global 0 Private Information Spread Information moved beyond the circle in which it was originally shared. Repair SYM_REPAIR 2 Resolve with Repair. Value: 2. None in the core set. H2: while unclaimed, +1 Stress at Round End to stress_scope=global (personal=owner; bond=owner's Bond network; global=all). BACK_PROBLEM_SURFACE
18 PRB_04_1 SCN_04 Hidden personal 1 Confidentiality Was Assumed The players never made the scope of confidentiality explicit. Clarify SYM_CLARIFY 2 Resolve with Clarify. Value: 2. None in the core set. H2: while unclaimed, +1 Stress at Round End to stress_scope=personal (personal=owner; bond=owner's Bond network; global=all). BACK_PROBLEM
19 PRB_04_2 SCN_04 Hidden personal 2 Exposure Caused Harm The sharing changed another player's safety, reputation, or freedom to choose. Repair SYM_REPAIR 2 Resolve with Repair. Value: 2. None in the core set. H2: while unclaimed, +1 Stress at Round End to stress_scope=personal (personal=owner; bond=owner's Bond network; global=all). BACK_PROBLEM
20 PRB_04_3 SCN_04 Hidden bond 3 Consent Boundary Was Ignored A clear or reasonably expected limit on sharing was crossed. Boundary SYM_BOUNDARY 3 Resolve with Boundary. Value: 3. None in the core set. H2: while unclaimed, +1 Stress at Round End to stress_scope=bond (personal=owner; bond=owner's Bond network; global=all). BACK_PROBLEM
21 PRB_04_4 SCN_04 Hidden personal 4 No Sharing Protocol The group lacked a repeatable rule for consent, need-to-know, and escalation. Change SYM_CHANGE 3 Resolve with Change. Value: 3. None in the core set. H2: while unclaimed, +1 Stress at Round End to stress_scope=personal (personal=owner; bond=owner's Bond network; global=all). BACK_PROBLEM