coulomb/clay-borg
4
0
Fork 0
Code Issues Pull requests Projects Releases Packages Wiki Activity Actions

ADR-0022 + CB-WP-0048 T00: the selector decision, and the mirror held

Browse source 
The maintainer's observation decided the design: aspects partition the
GAME, strata partition our apparatus, and they are orthogonal. A module
is one coordinate change in aspect space with an obligation in every
stratum. So aspect identity must NOT be Rust types -- an aspect
ground-game adds would make clay-borg fail to parse a configuration
rather than fail to run it, welding the two coordinate systems at the
one place they must stay independent.

Chosen: identity as data (Configuration round-trips anything the catalog
names), behaviour exhaustive (Rules, no catch-all), resolve() between.
Decisive argument: the catalog ALREADY ships modules with a rules_delta
and status: proposed, so a per-aspect enum would report them as "unknown
module" -- indistinguishable from a typo, a false statement about the
edition, and this project's signature failure shape. Two facts need two
errors. Federating design authority is permanent, so the representation
must outlive the implementation.

Legacy ids alias forever through the catalog's own legacy_experiment_id,
on the standard-Np precedent: 26 recordings name them and the expansion
is exact, so there is nothing to deprecate.

T00 done: the schema-2 mirror had arrived with no digests (19 files) and
edition-check was red. Digests are now generated by WALKING editions/,
not typed -- two reviews already found hand-written lists that made
their own controls vacuous, and a mirror that grows a directory is what
breaks a maintained list. PROVENANCE-catalog.md was a file inside the
mirrored tree that upstream does not have; folded into our own
PROVENANCE.md, since provenance about the mirror does not belong inside
the thing it describes.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
This commit is contained in:
tegwick 2026-08-08 22:07:57 +02:00
parent b39bc14861
commit bff64053ca
29 changed files with 1997 additions and 22 deletions
Download patch file Download diff file Expand all files Collapse all files

21
editions/modules/problem_stress/scoped/Problems.csv Normal file
View file

@ -0,0 +1,21 @@
problem_id,scenario_id,visibility,stress_scope,hidden_priority,title,problem_text,required_solution,symbol_id,point_value,front_rules,reveal_effect,unresolved_effect,back_design_id
PRB_01_S,SCN_01,Surface,global,0,Deadline Missed,A promised result was not delivered when expected.,Repair,SYM_REPAIR,2,Resolve with Repair. Value: 2.,None in the core set.,"H2: while unclaimed, +1 Stress at Round End to stress_scope=global (personal=owner; bond=owner's Bond network; global=all).",BACK_PROBLEM_SURFACE
PRB_01_1,SCN_01,Hidden,personal,1,Unclear Ownership,Responsibility for the commitment and the work was never made explicit.,Clarify,SYM_CLARIFY,2,Resolve with Clarify. Value: 2.,None in the core set.,"H2: while unclaimed, +1 Stress at Round End to stress_scope=personal (personal=owner; bond=owner's Bond network; global=all).",BACK_PROBLEM
PRB_01_2,SCN_01,Hidden,personal,2,Unspoken Overload,The work required more capacity than someone could safely or fairly provide.,Boundary,SYM_BOUNDARY,2,Resolve with Boundary. Value: 2.,None in the core set.,"H2: while unclaimed, +1 Stress at Round End to stress_scope=personal (personal=owner; bond=owner's Bond network; global=all).",BACK_PROBLEM
PRB_01_3,SCN_01,Hidden,bond,3,Bad News Was Delayed,A warning was withheld until the remaining options became worse.,Repair,SYM_REPAIR,3,Resolve with Repair. Value: 3.,None in the core set.,"H2: while unclaimed, +1 Stress at Round End to stress_scope=bond (personal=owner; bond=owner's Bond network; global=all).",BACK_PROBLEM
PRB_01_4,SCN_01,Hidden,personal,4,No Checkpoint Process,The group had no reliable moment for testing progress and changing course.,Change,SYM_CHANGE,3,Resolve with Change. Value: 3.,None in the core set.,"H2: while unclaimed, +1 Stress at Round End to stress_scope=personal (personal=owner; bond=owner's Bond network; global=all).",BACK_PROBLEM
PRB_02_S,SCN_02,Surface,global,0,Shared Task Left Undone,"A recurring responsibility was not completed, and others absorbed the impact.",Repair,SYM_REPAIR,2,Resolve with Repair. Value: 2.,None in the core set.,"H2: while unclaimed, +1 Stress at Round End to stress_scope=global (personal=owner; bond=owner's Bond network; global=all).",BACK_PROBLEM_SURFACE
PRB_02_1,SCN_02,Hidden,personal,1,Different Standards,"Players were using different definitions of complete, timely, or fair.",Clarify,SYM_CLARIFY,2,Resolve with Clarify. Value: 2.,None in the core set.,"H2: while unclaimed, +1 Stress at Round End to stress_scope=personal (personal=owner; bond=owner's Bond network; global=all).",BACK_PROBLEM
PRB_02_2,SCN_02,Hidden,personal,2,Invisible Workload,Some contributions and constraints were not visible to the group.,Boundary,SYM_BOUNDARY,2,Resolve with Boundary. Value: 2.,None in the core set.,"H2: while unclaimed, +1 Stress at Round End to stress_scope=personal (personal=owner; bond=owner's Bond network; global=all).",BACK_PROBLEM
PRB_02_3,SCN_02,Hidden,bond,3,Resentment Never Raised,Frustration accumulated without a direct request or acknowledgement.,Repair,SYM_REPAIR,3,Resolve with Repair. Value: 3.,None in the core set.,"H2: while unclaimed, +1 Stress at Round End to stress_scope=bond (personal=owner; bond=owner's Bond network; global=all).",BACK_PROBLEM
PRB_02_4,SCN_02,Hidden,personal,4,No Ownership Routine,The group relied on goodwill instead of a dependable allocation method.,Change,SYM_CHANGE,3,Resolve with Change. Value: 3.,None in the core set.,"H2: while unclaimed, +1 Stress at Round End to stress_scope=personal (personal=owner; bond=owner's Bond network; global=all).",BACK_PROBLEM
PRB_03_S,SCN_03,Surface,global,0,Decision Announced as Settled,A group-affecting choice was presented as final before meaningful agreement.,Boundary,SYM_BOUNDARY,2,Resolve with Boundary. Value: 2.,None in the core set.,"H2: while unclaimed, +1 Stress at Round End to stress_scope=global (personal=owner; bond=owner's Bond network; global=all).",BACK_PROBLEM_SURFACE
PRB_03_1,SCN_03,Hidden,personal,1,Mandate Was Ambiguous,"It was unclear who could decide, advise, consent, or veto.",Clarify,SYM_CLARIFY,2,Resolve with Clarify. Value: 2.,None in the core set.,"H2: while unclaimed, +1 Stress at Round End to stress_scope=personal (personal=owner; bond=owner's Bond network; global=all).",BACK_PROBLEM
PRB_03_2,SCN_03,Hidden,personal,2,Contributions Were Dismissed,Relevant input was ignored or treated as less legitimate.,Repair,SYM_REPAIR,2,Resolve with Repair. Value: 2.,None in the core set.,"H2: while unclaimed, +1 Stress at Round End to stress_scope=personal (personal=owner; bond=owner's Bond network; global=all).",BACK_PROBLEM
PRB_03_3,SCN_03,Hidden,bond,3,One Voice Spoke for Others,A player claimed authority to represent people who had not agreed.,Boundary,SYM_BOUNDARY,3,Resolve with Boundary. Value: 3.,None in the core set.,"H2: while unclaimed, +1 Stress at Round End to stress_scope=bond (personal=owner; bond=owner's Bond network; global=all).",BACK_PROBLEM
PRB_03_4,SCN_03,Hidden,personal,4,No Decision Rule,The group had no shared method for turning discussion into a legitimate choice.,Change,SYM_CHANGE,3,Resolve with Change. Value: 3.,None in the core set.,"H2: while unclaimed, +1 Stress at Round End to stress_scope=personal (personal=owner; bond=owner's Bond network; global=all).",BACK_PROBLEM
PRB_04_S,SCN_04,Surface,global,0,Private Information Spread,Information moved beyond the circle in which it was originally shared.,Repair,SYM_REPAIR,2,Resolve with Repair. Value: 2.,None in the core set.,"H2: while unclaimed, +1 Stress at Round End to stress_scope=global (personal=owner; bond=owner's Bond network; global=all).",BACK_PROBLEM_SURFACE
PRB_04_1,SCN_04,Hidden,personal,1,Confidentiality Was Assumed,The players never made the scope of confidentiality explicit.,Clarify,SYM_CLARIFY,2,Resolve with Clarify. Value: 2.,None in the core set.,"H2: while unclaimed, +1 Stress at Round End to stress_scope=personal (personal=owner; bond=owner's Bond network; global=all).",BACK_PROBLEM
PRB_04_2,SCN_04,Hidden,personal,2,Exposure Caused Harm,"The sharing changed another player's safety, reputation, or freedom to choose.",Repair,SYM_REPAIR,2,Resolve with Repair. Value: 2.,None in the core set.,"H2: while unclaimed, +1 Stress at Round End to stress_scope=personal (personal=owner; bond=owner's Bond network; global=all).",BACK_PROBLEM
PRB_04_3,SCN_04,Hidden,bond,3,Consent Boundary Was Ignored,A clear or reasonably expected limit on sharing was crossed.,Boundary,SYM_BOUNDARY,3,Resolve with Boundary. Value: 3.,None in the core set.,"H2: while unclaimed, +1 Stress at Round End to stress_scope=bond (personal=owner; bond=owner's Bond network; global=all).",BACK_PROBLEM
PRB_04_4,SCN_04,Hidden,personal,4,No Sharing Protocol,"The group lacked a repeatable rule for consent, need-to-know, and escalation.",Change,SYM_CHANGE,3,Resolve with Change. Value: 3.,None in the core set.,"H2: while unclaimed, +1 Stress at Round End to stress_scope=personal (personal=owner; bond=owner's Bond network; global=all).",BACK_PROBLEM
1 problem_id scenario_id visibility stress_scope hidden_priority title problem_text required_solution symbol_id point_value front_rules reveal_effect unresolved_effect back_design_id
2 PRB_01_S SCN_01 Surface global 0 Deadline Missed A promised result was not delivered when expected. Repair SYM_REPAIR 2 Resolve with Repair. Value: 2. None in the core set. H2: while unclaimed, +1 Stress at Round End to stress_scope=global (personal=owner; bond=owner's Bond network; global=all). BACK_PROBLEM_SURFACE
3 PRB_01_1 SCN_01 Hidden personal 1 Unclear Ownership Responsibility for the commitment and the work was never made explicit. Clarify SYM_CLARIFY 2 Resolve with Clarify. Value: 2. None in the core set. H2: while unclaimed, +1 Stress at Round End to stress_scope=personal (personal=owner; bond=owner's Bond network; global=all). BACK_PROBLEM
4 PRB_01_2 SCN_01 Hidden personal 2 Unspoken Overload The work required more capacity than someone could safely or fairly provide. Boundary SYM_BOUNDARY 2 Resolve with Boundary. Value: 2. None in the core set. H2: while unclaimed, +1 Stress at Round End to stress_scope=personal (personal=owner; bond=owner's Bond network; global=all). BACK_PROBLEM
5 PRB_01_3 SCN_01 Hidden bond 3 Bad News Was Delayed A warning was withheld until the remaining options became worse. Repair SYM_REPAIR 3 Resolve with Repair. Value: 3. None in the core set. H2: while unclaimed, +1 Stress at Round End to stress_scope=bond (personal=owner; bond=owner's Bond network; global=all). BACK_PROBLEM
6 PRB_01_4 SCN_01 Hidden personal 4 No Checkpoint Process The group had no reliable moment for testing progress and changing course. Change SYM_CHANGE 3 Resolve with Change. Value: 3. None in the core set. H2: while unclaimed, +1 Stress at Round End to stress_scope=personal (personal=owner; bond=owner's Bond network; global=all). BACK_PROBLEM
7 PRB_02_S SCN_02 Surface global 0 Shared Task Left Undone A recurring responsibility was not completed, and others absorbed the impact. Repair SYM_REPAIR 2 Resolve with Repair. Value: 2. None in the core set. H2: while unclaimed, +1 Stress at Round End to stress_scope=global (personal=owner; bond=owner's Bond network; global=all). BACK_PROBLEM_SURFACE
8 PRB_02_1 SCN_02 Hidden personal 1 Different Standards Players were using different definitions of complete, timely, or fair. Clarify SYM_CLARIFY 2 Resolve with Clarify. Value: 2. None in the core set. H2: while unclaimed, +1 Stress at Round End to stress_scope=personal (personal=owner; bond=owner's Bond network; global=all). BACK_PROBLEM
9 PRB_02_2 SCN_02 Hidden personal 2 Invisible Workload Some contributions and constraints were not visible to the group. Boundary SYM_BOUNDARY 2 Resolve with Boundary. Value: 2. None in the core set. H2: while unclaimed, +1 Stress at Round End to stress_scope=personal (personal=owner; bond=owner's Bond network; global=all). BACK_PROBLEM
10 PRB_02_3 SCN_02 Hidden bond 3 Resentment Never Raised Frustration accumulated without a direct request or acknowledgement. Repair SYM_REPAIR 3 Resolve with Repair. Value: 3. None in the core set. H2: while unclaimed, +1 Stress at Round End to stress_scope=bond (personal=owner; bond=owner's Bond network; global=all). BACK_PROBLEM
11 PRB_02_4 SCN_02 Hidden personal 4 No Ownership Routine The group relied on goodwill instead of a dependable allocation method. Change SYM_CHANGE 3 Resolve with Change. Value: 3. None in the core set. H2: while unclaimed, +1 Stress at Round End to stress_scope=personal (personal=owner; bond=owner's Bond network; global=all). BACK_PROBLEM
12 PRB_03_S SCN_03 Surface global 0 Decision Announced as Settled A group-affecting choice was presented as final before meaningful agreement. Boundary SYM_BOUNDARY 2 Resolve with Boundary. Value: 2. None in the core set. H2: while unclaimed, +1 Stress at Round End to stress_scope=global (personal=owner; bond=owner's Bond network; global=all). BACK_PROBLEM_SURFACE
13 PRB_03_1 SCN_03 Hidden personal 1 Mandate Was Ambiguous It was unclear who could decide, advise, consent, or veto. Clarify SYM_CLARIFY 2 Resolve with Clarify. Value: 2. None in the core set. H2: while unclaimed, +1 Stress at Round End to stress_scope=personal (personal=owner; bond=owner's Bond network; global=all). BACK_PROBLEM
14 PRB_03_2 SCN_03 Hidden personal 2 Contributions Were Dismissed Relevant input was ignored or treated as less legitimate. Repair SYM_REPAIR 2 Resolve with Repair. Value: 2. None in the core set. H2: while unclaimed, +1 Stress at Round End to stress_scope=personal (personal=owner; bond=owner's Bond network; global=all). BACK_PROBLEM
15 PRB_03_3 SCN_03 Hidden bond 3 One Voice Spoke for Others A player claimed authority to represent people who had not agreed. Boundary SYM_BOUNDARY 3 Resolve with Boundary. Value: 3. None in the core set. H2: while unclaimed, +1 Stress at Round End to stress_scope=bond (personal=owner; bond=owner's Bond network; global=all). BACK_PROBLEM
16 PRB_03_4 SCN_03 Hidden personal 4 No Decision Rule The group had no shared method for turning discussion into a legitimate choice. Change SYM_CHANGE 3 Resolve with Change. Value: 3. None in the core set. H2: while unclaimed, +1 Stress at Round End to stress_scope=personal (personal=owner; bond=owner's Bond network; global=all). BACK_PROBLEM
17 PRB_04_S SCN_04 Surface global 0 Private Information Spread Information moved beyond the circle in which it was originally shared. Repair SYM_REPAIR 2 Resolve with Repair. Value: 2. None in the core set. H2: while unclaimed, +1 Stress at Round End to stress_scope=global (personal=owner; bond=owner's Bond network; global=all). BACK_PROBLEM_SURFACE
18 PRB_04_1 SCN_04 Hidden personal 1 Confidentiality Was Assumed The players never made the scope of confidentiality explicit. Clarify SYM_CLARIFY 2 Resolve with Clarify. Value: 2. None in the core set. H2: while unclaimed, +1 Stress at Round End to stress_scope=personal (personal=owner; bond=owner's Bond network; global=all). BACK_PROBLEM
19 PRB_04_2 SCN_04 Hidden personal 2 Exposure Caused Harm The sharing changed another player's safety, reputation, or freedom to choose. Repair SYM_REPAIR 2 Resolve with Repair. Value: 2. None in the core set. H2: while unclaimed, +1 Stress at Round End to stress_scope=personal (personal=owner; bond=owner's Bond network; global=all). BACK_PROBLEM
20 PRB_04_3 SCN_04 Hidden bond 3 Consent Boundary Was Ignored A clear or reasonably expected limit on sharing was crossed. Boundary SYM_BOUNDARY 3 Resolve with Boundary. Value: 3. None in the core set. H2: while unclaimed, +1 Stress at Round End to stress_scope=bond (personal=owner; bond=owner's Bond network; global=all). BACK_PROBLEM
21 PRB_04_4 SCN_04 Hidden personal 4 No Sharing Protocol The group lacked a repeatable rule for consent, need-to-know, and escalation. Change SYM_CHANGE 3 Resolve with Change. Value: 3. None in the core set. H2: while unclaimed, +1 Stress at Round End to stress_scope=personal (personal=owner; bond=owner's Bond network; global=all). BACK_PROBLEM