tegwick
0f64961d06
Some checks failed
ci / check (push) Failing after 3s
CB-EV-0030 concluded H1's DARVO arm rate was still 0. That was true of the panel, and the panel was greedy-family throughout. GreedyPolicy ranks `Ground if gated => 100`, so it grounds the instant the stress gate bites, Stress plateaus at 3, and the arm at 5 is unreachable by construction. "H1 does nothing" was really "H1 does nothing to a seat that already manages its Stress" — and H1 was written for the seat that does not. `reactive` is greedy with exactly one preference changed: GROUND demoted below ATTACK. Under it, H1's criteria 1 and 2 are MET — DARVO arms 400 times per cell, ATTACK is chosen 3 times per seat per game. Criterion 3 fails harder: reactive wins nothing at any seat count. The larger finding is about the baseline. Greedy and reactive play IDENTICALLY under baseline, and peak Stress across 3,200 baseline games was 1 — against a starting value of 2. The gate at 4, the DARVO arm at 5 and the Freedom token are all unreachable, and a policy built to be reckless with Stress is indistinguishable from one built to husband it. That is a deeper account of F17 than F17 has. Not raised as a finding yet: it wants the plural panel first. A constant was investigated rather than reported: darvo was exactly 400 in every cell while atk scaled with seats. Six-player final Stress is [5,5,4,4,4,4] every seed — H1-B holds the attacker at 4, below the arm, and pushes its targets to 5. The self-soothe suppresses DARVO in the aggressor and concentrates it in the attacked. The direction follows from H1-B's arithmetic; the number 2 is partly an artifact of reactive's first-legal targeting, and is labelled as such. Still unreviewed: tier L review outstanding on CB-WP-0038, and nothing here reaches ground-game until it runs. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
149 lines
2.3 KiB
YAML
149 lines
2.3 KiB
YAML
scenario: ground/cb-play-session
|
|
description: recorded by cb-play (CB-WP-0008 T02)
|
|
covers: []
|
|
provisional: false
|
|
provisional_owner: ''
|
|
provisional_raised: ''
|
|
ruled: ''
|
|
ruled_by: ''
|
|
ruled_note: ''
|
|
encodes_u_item: ''
|
|
seed: 1
|
|
setup:
|
|
players: 3
|
|
preset: standard-3p
|
|
patch: {}
|
|
commands:
|
|
- actor: P1
|
|
cmd: select_action
|
|
args:
|
|
action: INVESTIGATE
|
|
problem: 2
|
|
- actor: P2
|
|
cmd: select_action
|
|
args:
|
|
action: SOLVE
|
|
problem: 1
|
|
- actor: P3
|
|
cmd: select_action
|
|
args:
|
|
action: SOLVE
|
|
problem: 1
|
|
- actor: SYSTEM
|
|
cmd: reveal
|
|
args: {}
|
|
- actor: SYSTEM
|
|
cmd: resolve
|
|
args: {}
|
|
- actor: SYSTEM
|
|
cmd: end_round
|
|
args: {}
|
|
- actor: P1
|
|
cmd: select_action
|
|
args:
|
|
action: INVESTIGATE
|
|
problem: 3
|
|
- actor: P2
|
|
cmd: select_action
|
|
args:
|
|
action: INVESTIGATE
|
|
problem: 3
|
|
- actor: P3
|
|
cmd: select_action
|
|
args:
|
|
action: INVESTIGATE
|
|
problem: 3
|
|
- actor: SYSTEM
|
|
cmd: reveal
|
|
args: {}
|
|
- actor: SYSTEM
|
|
cmd: resolve
|
|
args: {}
|
|
- actor: SYSTEM
|
|
cmd: end_round
|
|
args: {}
|
|
- actor: P1
|
|
cmd: select_action
|
|
args:
|
|
action: SOLVE
|
|
problem: 2
|
|
- actor: P2
|
|
cmd: select_action
|
|
args:
|
|
action: INVESTIGATE
|
|
problem: 4
|
|
- actor: P3
|
|
cmd: select_action
|
|
args:
|
|
action: SOLVE
|
|
problem: 2
|
|
- actor: SYSTEM
|
|
cmd: reveal
|
|
args: {}
|
|
- actor: SYSTEM
|
|
cmd: resolve
|
|
args: {}
|
|
- actor: SYSTEM
|
|
cmd: end_round
|
|
args: {}
|
|
- actor: P1
|
|
cmd: select_action
|
|
args:
|
|
action: SOLVE
|
|
problem: 3
|
|
- actor: P2
|
|
cmd: select_action
|
|
args:
|
|
action: SOLVE
|
|
problem: 3
|
|
- actor: P3
|
|
cmd: select_action
|
|
args:
|
|
action: SOLVE
|
|
problem: 4
|
|
- actor: SYSTEM
|
|
cmd: reveal
|
|
args: {}
|
|
- actor: SYSTEM
|
|
cmd: resolve
|
|
args: {}
|
|
- actor: SYSTEM
|
|
cmd: end_round
|
|
args: {}
|
|
- actor: P1
|
|
cmd: select_action
|
|
args:
|
|
action: SUPPORT
|
|
target: P3
|
|
- actor: P2
|
|
cmd: select_action
|
|
args:
|
|
action: SUPPORT
|
|
target: P1
|
|
- actor: P3
|
|
cmd: select_action
|
|
args:
|
|
action: SUPPORT
|
|
target: P1
|
|
- actor: SYSTEM
|
|
cmd: reveal
|
|
args: {}
|
|
- actor: P1
|
|
cmd: respond_to_support
|
|
args:
|
|
response: accept_bond
|
|
- actor: P3
|
|
cmd: respond_to_support
|
|
args:
|
|
response: accept_bond
|
|
- actor: SYSTEM
|
|
cmd: resolve
|
|
args: {}
|
|
- actor: SYSTEM
|
|
cmd: end_round
|
|
args: {}
|
|
expect:
|
|
events: []
|
|
state: {}
|
|
rejects: []
|
|
state_hash: 0e9629eec89de6c479a617d2b8929819c502fc6d1020b30a871fe23ad8ea1a1b
|