Record FIAM review of InterfaceCanon derivation boundary

Assistant: codex
Assistant-Model: gpt-6-astra
Assistant-Session: 01a087b0-7b1e-7531-8ef3-6525ebaf7ee7
This commit is contained in:
tegwick 2026-09-09 22:31:32 +02:00
parent 1353267569
commit cceb005c9c
3 changed files with 93 additions and 0 deletions

View file

@ -13,3 +13,8 @@ make -C history/FIAM_v0.2_Draft6 check
Normative releases should be promoted into a versioned top-level release
layout; `history/` remains reserved for superseded drafts.
## InterfaceCanon boundary
See the [accepted InterfaceCanon derivation review](docs/interface-canon-boundary.md)
for source revisions, findings, and the scope of acceptance.

View file

@ -0,0 +1,42 @@
# InterfaceCanon derivation boundary
Status: accepted for the reviewed draft derivation and authority boundary.
Reviewer: Codex acting for facetted-interfaces under the repository task request.
Review date: 2026-09-09.
Reviewed InterfaceCanon interface-model 0.1.1 at
`1fc82ec6655ed286cea3be284e33d08e7b27edc3`, specifically
`infospace/models/interface/InterfaceCanonInterfaceModel.md` and
`infospace/assimilation/fiam/sources.json`. Request package:
`6b33ac2388190207c4373e6f288922ce5c0b0413`, INTERFACE-WP-0004-T01;
State Hub request `cb3a7690-f145-4559-969f-c6f800994de0`.
InterfaceCanon translates FIAM interface terminology into a focused extension
to InfoTechCanon. FIAM retains authority over standard semantics, Core schemas,
controlled terms, profiles, policies, reference implementation, and conformance.
InterfaceCanon owns its derived presentation and cross-canon mappings.
The consumer pins FIAM v0.2 Draft 6 at
`135326756913363b098bcdee791628b5e864b8be`, including the retained Draft 1
explanation, frozen Core schema, and Canon. All four source manifest hashes
were verified against that commit.
## Review findings
| Distinction | FIAM evidence | Assessment |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Contract versus binding | Core `contractParticipation`, `binding`; Draft 1 structural spine | Preserved; offers/requires concerns participation and multiple realizations can share a contract. |
| Endpoint versus resource selector | Core `endpoint`, `resourceSelector`, `binding.endpoints` | Preserved; endpoint reuse does not imply resource identity. |
| Channel versus retained resource | Draft 1 structural spine and Kafka example | Preserved; exchange and retained information remain distinct roles. |
| Shape versus artifact versus representation | Core `informationShape`; Draft 1 hardening §§3–5 | Preserved; representation remains scoped to shape-participation assertions. |
| Assertions versus lens conclusions | Core `assertion`; Draft 6 §§1, 6–7 | Preserved; unknown evidence and policy-dependent interpretations remain explicit. |
No blocking semantic corrections were found in this reviewed model. Its prose
is an explanatory summary: exact required fields, optionality, controlled terms,
and validation remain governed by FIAM's source artifacts and validators.
Acceptance is limited to fidelity of this derivation and its authority boundary.
It does not promote either draft to stable, certify consumer runtime conformance,
or change the identity/commerce ownership ledger. Future source revisions need
a new review. This document is the repository's review receipt; its Git commit
identifies the applied peer change.

View file

@ -0,0 +1,46 @@
---
id: FIAM-WP-0002
type: workplan
title: "Review and apply InterfaceCanon derivation boundary"
domain: infotech
repo: facetted-interfaces
status: finished
owner: codex
topic_slug: canon
created: "2026-09-09"
updated: "2026-09-09"
spec_refs:
- INTENT.md
- docs/interface-canon-boundary.md
---
# FIAM-WP-0002 — InterfaceCanon boundary review
Handle State Hub request `cb3a7690-f145-4559-969f-c6f800994de0` from
interface-canon for INTERFACE-WP-0004-T01.
## T01 — Review pinned derivation and source provenance
```task
id: FIAM-WP-0002-T01
status: done
priority: high
```
Compared interface-model 0.1.1 at `1fc82ec6655ed286cea3be284e33d08e7b27edc3`
with FIAM Core and Draft 1/Draft 6 explanations. Verified all four manifest
source hashes against FIAM commit `135326756913363b098bcdee791628b5e864b8be`.
The five requested semantic distinctions are preserved; no blocking corrections.
## T02 — Apply boundary document and record acceptance
```task
id: FIAM-WP-0002-T02
status: done
priority: high
```
Added `docs/interface-canon-boundary.md` and README navigation. The receipt
records reviewer identity, exact revisions, evidence, and limited acceptance.
Validated source locators and local document links. No runtime changes.
The review is available to the requesting repository in this committed receipt.