{
  "adjudicator": "Codex",
  "adjudicated_at": "2026-09-26",
  "condition_masked": false,
  "independent_human_validation": false,
  "original_scores_preserved": "../editorial-scores-masked.json",
  "submitted_scores_preserved": "scores.json",
  "source_sha256": "9bb6f4c87d7220ba4d8b992590e73c6d7bc7b0e2d4e4d4702f24cd34d1aa6e01",
  "binary_ratings_compared": 48,
  "unchanged_ratings": 44,
  "changed_ratings": [
    {
      "answer": "S02-V",
      "criterion": "Q",
      "original": 1,
      "submitted": 0,
      "condition": "patterns",
      "disposition": "accept submitted score",
      "reason": "The rubric requires lookup plus retention, or recovery of the old operation/device identity. Retention alone is only partial coverage."
    },
    {
      "answer": "S04-U",
      "criterion": "R",
      "original": 1,
      "submitted": 0,
      "condition": "patterns",
      "disposition": "accept submitted score",
      "reason": "Provider escalation is present, but the compound criterion also requires distinguishing an authorized remote reversal if K was accepted."
    },
    {
      "answer": "S04-U",
      "criterion": "Q",
      "original": 1,
      "submitted": 0,
      "condition": "patterns",
      "disposition": "accept submitted score",
      "reason": "Lookup and retention are mentioned, but the required remote cancellation contract is omitted."
    },
    {
      "answer": "S04-V",
      "criterion": "Q",
      "original": 1,
      "submitted": 0,
      "condition": "prose",
      "disposition": "accept submitted score",
      "reason": "Duplicate handling and retention are mentioned, but lookup/history and remote cancellation semantics are omitted."
    }
  ],
  "conditions": {
    "patterns": {
      "criteria_met": {
        "C1": 5,
        "C2": 6,
        "R": 4,
        "Q": 3
      },
      "requirements_possible": 24,
      "requirements_met": 18,
      "missed_requirements": 6
    },
    "prose": {
      "criteria_met": {
        "C1": 5,
        "C2": 6,
        "R": 3,
        "Q": 4
      },
      "requirements_possible": 24,
      "requirements_met": 18,
      "missed_requirements": 6
    }
  },
  "unsupported_claims": "Narrative annotations preserved and adjudicated in adjudication.md; no submitted numeric count or uniform counting unit inferred. Original counts remain historical.",
  "pair_advantage_recomputed": false,
  "conclusion": "No demonstrated presentation benefit. Equal aggregate obligation counts do not establish equivalence; independent human validation remains pending."
}