reviewer: Codex
reviewed_at: '2026-09-25'
workspace: research/bench/infospaces/kubernetes-stale-writes-01
receipt_sha256: 2a03de68834cb91f1d276a05a9260bf50fe54cc857072313a4e1241ee93ca933
question: What does stale-version rejection establish about frontend recovery?
disposition: revise
rejected_assertions:
  - artifact: artifacts/generated/candidates.md
    locator: P01 Resulting Context
    assertion: The server state remains unchanged.
    reason: Only this rejected attempt makes no change; other writers may continue changing state.
corrections:
  - artifact: artifacts/generated/candidates.md
    locator: P01 Candidate Identity
    before: 'family Concurrency Control; scale Interaction'
    after: 'families [mutation, authority]; scales [L2, L6]'
    evidence: canon/PatternSchema.md and canon/Scales.md
  - artifact: artifacts/generated/candidates.md
    locator: P01 Forces
    before: Client autonomy and disconnected work presented without an inference label.
    after: Treat these as proposed forces, not observed offline behavior.
    evidence: SRC-0008 excerpt establishes rejection only.
  - artifact: artifacts/generated/candidates.md
    locator: P01 Resulting Context
    before: The server state remains unchanged.
    after: The rejected attempt does not commit its proposed update.
    evidence: T01 in TransactionalEvidenceExpansion.md
  - artifact: artifacts/generated/claims.md
    locator: C01 and C02
    before: Two separate claims from the same stale-version rejection sentence.
    after: Consolidate as T01; do not count as independent evidence.
    evidence: SRC-0008 identical source locator.
remaining_questions:
  - Locate independent frontend implementations of draft retention and outcome recovery.
  - Verify operation identity, atomic validation and retention contracts in a real implementation.
notes: >-
  Two service calls through llm-connect; 2849 reported tokens; two deterministic
  stages; no structural rejection. The structural gate does not validate vocabulary
  or semantics. One generated candidate was narrowed into the editorial
  Version-Checked Mutation draft. Original artifacts and receipt remain immutable.
  Known uses and recurrence remain conservatively unknown for the frontend configuration.