2026-09-09 22:48:09 +02:00
# InterfaceCanon extension boundary
Status: accepted for the semantic boundary documented below, reviewed by Codex
in the InfoTechCanon repository on 2026-09-09. This is an agent review, not a
claim of separate human sign-off or a published peer merge.
Review target: interface-canon draft 0.1.1 at
`1fc82ec6655ed286cea3be284e33d08e7b27edc3` . Proposed patch: interface-canon
`reviews/INTERFACE-WP-0004/info-tech-canon.patch` in review package
`6b33ac2388190207c4373e6f288922ce5c0b0413` .
InfoTechCanon review base and import source:
`8eb1c83f2e119de57e7ad448b901381f8e92fb57` .
InterfaceCanon derives interface-domain terminology from FIAM in
facetted-interfaces and references shared InfoTechCanon concepts. It supplies a
focused interface model while InfoTechCanon retains the shared roots.
## Accepted dispositions
- FIAM Port is contract participation, distinct from ITC-NET network Port.
Network profiles also distinguish physical/device ports from transport ports;
the distinction is broader than the TCP example alone.
- InterfaceContract describes semantic interface behavior. Landscape's Interface
seed and Network's attachment-point Interface are contextual mappings, not
universal exact aliases.
- FIAM Endpoint locates or selects a Binding. Network Endpoint is related where
realization is network-based; local bindings need not have a network endpoint.
- InformationResource/InformationShape map contextually to Data concepts.
Dataset, DataObject, Record, DataType, and Constraint retain their shared owners;
these mappings establish neither universal subtyping nor exact equivalence.
- FIAM Representation concerns participation encoding; Data Representation also
describes value-level forms. Consumers must qualify these scopes.
- Describing artifacts may be KnowledgeArtifact and Evidence Source. An Evidence
Source is an addressable container with a relevant version or capture where
mutable; Evidence is a separate assertion drawn for an explicit interest.
An artifact implementing a contract is not automatically a KnowledgeArtifact.
## Evidence and limits
Reviewed `infospace/models/interface/InterfaceCanonInterfaceModel.md` ,
`infospace/mappings/review-2026-09-09.md` , and
`infospace/models/interface/imports.json` at the InterfaceCanon revision above.
All seven manifest SHA-256 values match Git blobs at the declared InfoTechCanon
source revision, and those files are unchanged in the review checkout:
ITC-LAND, ITC-IDENT, ITC-EVID, ITC-GOV, ITC-DATA, ITC-INFOSPACE, and ITC-NET.
The proposed boundary is accepted with the clarifications above. This reciprocal
reference does not extend the completed identity/commerce ownership ledger,
transfer shared ownership, or establish a reverse semantic dependency.
InterfaceCanon remains draft; this review supplies no consumer implementation or
deployment evidence and does not satisfy INFO-WP-0019-T06's emission-cadence gate.
The file's eventual containing commit identifies the applied review revision;
the review base above must not be represented as a merge commit. Work and
verification are tracked in
[INFO-WP-0026 ](../../workplans/INFO-WP-0026-interface-canon-boundary-review.md ).
2026-09-20 23:27:47 +02:00
## Re-verification — 2026-09-20 (INFO-WP-0027-T04)
Re-run against the enlarged InfoTechCanon ownership index (750 entries, up from
164) after INFO-WP-0027-T02. Twenty-one of InterfaceCanon's twenty-five declared
imports resolve by name to the artifact they are pinned to. No ownership
conflict is introduced by the enlarged index.
Four do not resolve, and two of the four were InfoTechCanon's omission rather
than InterfaceCanon's:
| Import | Pinned to | Finding |
| --- | --- | --- |
| `SoftwareSystem` | ITC-LAND | Defined in a Landscape seed-concept list, which declaration extraction cannot read. Now declared in the Landscape Model; the pin is correct. |
| `SoftwareComponent` | ITC-LAND | Same. Now declared; the pin is correct. |
| `Interface` | ITC-LAND | Declared by the Network Model, not Landscape. The clarification above already treats Landscape's Interface seed and Network's attachment-point Interface as contextual mappings rather than exact aliases, so the name resolves to Network and the Landscape pin should be qualified or re-pointed. |
| `Endpoint` | ITC-LAND | Same as Interface. Network owns the name; the Landscape sense is contextual. |
No InfoTechCanon concept is renamed, moved or removed, and the accepted
dispositions are unchanged. The `Interface` and `Endpoint` pins are
InterfaceCanon's to correct; the two Landscape declarations are made here.
Check import manifests by hash and name together (INFO-WP-0028 T01-T03)
import-review takes any partner manifest and returns, per concept, whether the
name resolves in the ownership index and to which artifact, and per entry
whether the pinned SHA-256 matches the blob at the declared source commit. Both
run in one pass so neither can be recorded without the other, which is the
failure this workplan exists to prevent. It exits non-zero on a finding, reads
JSON or YAML, needs no partner checkout, and carries its own limit: resolution
proves a name exists and names one owner, nothing more.
Accepted manifests are registered under infospace/interfaces/manifests/ as
provenance-preserving copies owned by the partner, with the partner revision and
retrieval date recorded. Editing a copy to make a check pass is forbidden in the
file itself. Validation re-resolves them and reports drift as
federation_import_drift, a warning naming the partner rather than an error,
because a stale partner pin is not this repository's file to fix.
The review kit gains an extension-boundary-review template requiring hash count,
resolution count and conflict count as three separate lines, and an operating
rule saying one is never evidence of another. Both boundary files carry the
standing-check result.
Verified live: security-canon resolves 11 of 11, interface-canon 23 of 25 with
the two known Interface and Endpoint pins. make check passes with 58 tests,
clean validation and those two warnings.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Assistant: claude-code
Assistant-Model: opus
Assistant-Process: 3588@bnt-lap001
Assistant-Session: 24b80f66-e5a7-4e61-99fe-2d422e6d17da
2026-09-20 23:43:34 +02:00
## Standing check — 2026-09-20 (INFO-WP-0028)
This partner's import manifest is registered at
`infospace/interfaces/manifests/interface-canon.json` as a provenance-preserving copy and is
re-resolved on every `make check` . Hash and name are checked together by
`info_tech_canon import-review` ; a name that stops resolving, or resolves to a
different owner than the manifest pins, is reported as a
`federation_import_drift` warning naming this partner. It is a warning and not an
error because a stale partner pin is not this repository's file to fix.
Close the last open import pins and the workplan (T04)
interface-canon corrected its Interface and Endpoint pins at 20d7bfc2. Both were
pinned twice, to ITC-LAND and ITC-NET, because ITC-LAND section 13.2 lists them
in a seed-concept block while the Network Model defines them. Landscape section
13.2 now says in this repository that Interface, Endpoint and API are pointers
there and that the Network Model owns the first two, so the next reader does not
repeat it.
That is the fourth time in one day a list of concept names was read as a
definition, after CARING's Scope ladder, CARING's Environment values, and the
Landscape seeds that hid SoftwareSystem and SoftwareComponent. The closure
section names the pattern.
Both boundaries now resolve completely, security-canon 11 of 11 and
interface-canon 23 of 23, the registered copy is refreshed to the corrected
revision, and validation carries no drift warnings. The CLI test is rebuilt from
a deliberately broken copy so that a partner fixing its own pins can no longer
break this repository's suite.
make check passes with 59 tests, clean validation and no warnings.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Assistant: claude-code
Assistant-Model: opus
Assistant-Process: 3588@bnt-lap001
Assistant-Session: 24b80f66-e5a7-4e61-99fe-2d422e6d17da
2026-09-20 23:50:52 +02:00
Current result: **23 of 23 declared imports resolve** , all seven pinned hashes
match, no drift.
The `Interface` and `Endpoint` pins were corrected in interface-canon at
`20d7bfc2` on 2026-09-20. Both names had been pinned twice, to ITC-LAND and to
ITC-NET; the ITC-LAND pins are dropped, since section 13.2 lists them as pointers
while the Network Model defines and owns them. Landscape section 13.2 now says so
in InfoTechCanon, so the next reader does not repeat it. The accepted
dispositions are unchanged: this was a citation fix, and the mapping tables that
cite ITC-LAND section 13.2 as a related seed stand as they are.