tegwick
f2d216af53
§10.3 now accepts a consumer record that validates against the live catalog; resource-control's backup restatement is that proof. ITC-GOV gains EvidenceBasis in tiers (invoiced and measured are peers) and ITC-CAP requires it on every consumption row (CAP-R10).
110 lines
4.3 KiB
YAML
110 lines
4.3 KiB
YAML
# InfoTechCanon Evidence Basis Catalog
|
|
#
|
|
# How a quantity was obtained. Owned by ITC-GOV; imported by CapabilityConsumption
|
|
# (CAP-R10) and reusable on any measured or modelled value.
|
|
#
|
|
# Adapted from demand/EvidenceBasis.md (resource-control). Strength is a tier,
|
|
# not a total order: invoiced and measured are peers. The consumer's first
|
|
# implementation used a strict list rank and corrected it.
|
|
canon:
|
|
id: itc-gov-evidence-basis
|
|
name: InfoTechCanon Evidence Basis
|
|
artifact_id: catalog/evidence-basis
|
|
version: 0.1.0
|
|
status: draft
|
|
canon_version: 0.4.0
|
|
owner: model/governance
|
|
purpose: Closed scale for how a quantity was obtained, with a propagation rule
|
|
and decision grades. Tiers, not a spurious total order.
|
|
normative_document: models/governance/InfoTechCanonGovernanceModel.md
|
|
provenance:
|
|
demand: demand/EvidenceBasis.md
|
|
consumer: resource-control
|
|
consumer_docs:
|
|
- docs/evidence-basis.md
|
|
- tools/basis.py
|
|
bases:
|
|
- id: invoiced
|
|
tier: evidenced
|
|
description: Taken from an authoritative financial record. This canon names
|
|
the basis; it does not originate booked costs, tax, or currency semantics.
|
|
- id: measured
|
|
tier: evidenced
|
|
description: Directly observed from the authoritative system.
|
|
- id: quoted
|
|
tier: evidenced
|
|
description: Stated by a provider or counterparty in a citable source.
|
|
- id: derived
|
|
tier: null
|
|
description: Computed from other values by a stated rule. Not a resolved
|
|
tier — effective basis is the weakest input.
|
|
- id: projected
|
|
tier: projected
|
|
description: Interpolated between, or extrapolated beyond, observations.
|
|
- id: estimated
|
|
tier: judgement
|
|
description: Human judgement, neither observed nor computed.
|
|
- id: assumed
|
|
tier: judgement
|
|
description: A modelling constant chosen by the author.
|
|
- id: unknown
|
|
tier: unknown
|
|
description: No value exists. MUST NOT carry a quantity. MUST name the gap
|
|
and its owner.
|
|
# Strongest to weakest. Members of one tier are peers: weakest() among only
|
|
# invoiced and measured MUST NOT imply a ranking.
|
|
tiers:
|
|
- id: evidenced
|
|
rank: 0
|
|
members: [invoiced, measured, quoted]
|
|
note: invoiced and measured are peers. quoted is evidenced for grading but
|
|
does not outrank or sit below a measurement of a different quantity.
|
|
- id: projected
|
|
rank: 1
|
|
members: [projected]
|
|
- id: judgement
|
|
rank: 2
|
|
members: [estimated, assumed]
|
|
note: both yield decision grade indicative; they are not ranked against
|
|
each other.
|
|
- id: unknown
|
|
rank: 3
|
|
members: [unknown]
|
|
rules:
|
|
- id: weakest-input-wins
|
|
statement: A derived value is only as strong as its weakest input, compared
|
|
by tier. Members of the same tier do not rank against each other.
|
|
- id: unknown-is-not-zero
|
|
statement: Basis unknown carries no quantity. Any other basis MUST carry a
|
|
quantity. Zero means measured-and-none; unknown means not measured.
|
|
- id: derived-names-inputs
|
|
statement: A derived value MUST record derived_from. Only a derived value
|
|
MAY record derived_from.
|
|
- id: invoiced-not-originated
|
|
statement: invoiced names a booked fact owned elsewhere. This catalog does
|
|
not define ledger semantics.
|
|
- id: tiers-not-total-order
|
|
statement: Strength is a tier, not a total order. weakest([invoiced,
|
|
measured]) MUST NOT imply that one outranks the other.
|
|
qualifiers:
|
|
- id: proxy_for
|
|
description: The value measures a different quantity than the one being
|
|
reasoned about. It does not weaken the measurement; it weakens the
|
|
inference.
|
|
- id: observed_at
|
|
description: When a measurement was taken. Age and sample size are not
|
|
basis. A value may be measured and still be a single noisy sample.
|
|
decision_grades:
|
|
- id: evidenced
|
|
when: Every load-bearing value resolves to the evidenced tier.
|
|
- id: projected
|
|
when: The weakest resolved tier is projected.
|
|
- id: indicative
|
|
when: The weakest resolved tier is judgement (estimated or assumed).
|
|
- id: insufficient
|
|
when: At least one load-bearing value is unknown.
|
|
note: >
|
|
EvidenceBasis is how a quantity was obtained. It is not the
|
|
intended/declared/applied/observed/assessed state qualifier (OQ-3). Those
|
|
name which world a claim is about; this names how a number in that world
|
|
was produced.
|