---
entity_slug: merchantable_herrings
evaluator: null
evaluated_at: '2026-02-23T05:51:50.787158'
overall_score: 4.2
scores:
- name: definition_precision
  value: 4.0
  max_value: 5.0
  rationale: The definition clearly distinguishes merchantable herrings from other
    forms (like sea-sticks) by specifying the additional processing requirements of
    salting and packaging for commercial sale. It captures a distinct stage in the
    fish processing chain rather than being vague or circular.
- name: source_grounding
  value: 5.0
  max_value: 5.0
  rationale: This entity is directly grounded in Smith's discussion in Book IV, Chapter
    5, where he explicitly contrasts merchantable herrings with sea-sticks to illustrate
    how bounties distort pricing in the fishing industry. The concept emerges naturally
    from Smith's own analysis.
- name: domain_placement
  value: 5.0
  max_value: 5.0
  rationale: The "Production" domain assignment is correct, as merchantable herrings
    represent a specific stage in the production process where raw fish are transformed
    into market-ready commodities. This fits perfectly within production economics
    rather than trade or consumption domains.
- name: vsm_relevance
  value: 3.0
  max_value: 5.0
  rationale: This entity maps most naturally to S1 (primary operations) as a specific
    production output, but it's primarily a product category rather than a systemic
    function. While it has some VSM relevance through its role in production operations,
    it's more of a concrete output than a system component.
- name: explanatory_value
  value: 4.0
  max_value: 5.0
  rationale: The entity provides genuine explanatory value by illustrating how government
    bounties can create artificial distinctions and pricing structures in commodity
    markets. It serves as a concrete example of how subsidies distort natural market
    mechanisms and pricing relationships.
---

# Evaluation: Merchantable Herrings

## definition_precision — 4.0 / 5.0

The definition clearly distinguishes merchantable herrings from other forms (like sea-sticks) by specifying the additional processing requirements of salting and packaging for commercial sale. It captures a distinct stage in the fish processing chain rather than being vague or circular.

## source_grounding — 5.0 / 5.0

This entity is directly grounded in Smith's discussion in Book IV, Chapter 5, where he explicitly contrasts merchantable herrings with sea-sticks to illustrate how bounties distort pricing in the fishing industry. The concept emerges naturally from Smith's own analysis.

## domain_placement — 5.0 / 5.0

The "Production" domain assignment is correct, as merchantable herrings represent a specific stage in the production process where raw fish are transformed into market-ready commodities. This fits perfectly within production economics rather than trade or consumption domains.

## vsm_relevance — 3.0 / 5.0

This entity maps most naturally to S1 (primary operations) as a specific production output, but it's primarily a product category rather than a systemic function. While it has some VSM relevance through its role in production operations, it's more of a concrete output than a system component.

## explanatory_value — 4.0 / 5.0

The entity provides genuine explanatory value by illustrating how government bounties can create artificial distinctions and pricing structures in commodity markets. It serves as a concrete example of how subsidies distort natural market mechanisms and pricing relationships.
