Accept ADR-0009 with tenant-selectable isolation upgrade path

Add shared-realm and dedicated-instance tiers selected by the IAM capability
role, binding reference points (issuer invariance, subject preservation,
tier-neutral declaration, drill), and NK-WP-0011-T09.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>

Assistant: claude-code
Assistant-Model: sonnet
Assistant-Process: 295952@bnt-lap001
Assistant-Session: e93f64ad-516c-46eb-9666-aad8d300c477

docs/adr/ADR-0009-expanded-mode-keycloak-federation-topology.md

@@ -2,17 +2,17 @@
 id: NK-ADR-0009
 type: architecture-decision-record
 title: "Expanded-Mode Keycloak: Adoption Trigger and Federation Topology"
-status: proposed
+status: accepted
 owner: net-kingdom
 revision: "1"
-proposed: "2026-09-28"
+decided: "2026-09-28"
 last_reviewed: "2026-09-28"
 review_interval: 12m
 ---
 
 # ADR-0009 - Expanded-Mode Keycloak: Adoption Trigger and Federation Topology
 
-**Status:** Proposed (awaiting Bernd's decision; NK-WP-0011-T01)
+**Status:** Accepted 2026-09-28, with the isolation-upgrade amendment in decision 3 (NK-WP-0011-T01)
 **Date:** 2026-09-28
 **Deciders:** Bernd Worsch, Claude
 
@@ -32,7 +32,7 @@ node with single-instance databases, so no option here buys HA.
 NK-WP-0001 decision D2 (Keycloak as primary internal user store) predates all
 of this.
 
-## Decision (proposed)
+## Decision
 
 1. **Trigger.** A tenant moves to expanded mode only when all three hold: a
    named tenant, a named owner of the upstream IdP, and a concrete federation
@@ -45,15 +45,51 @@ of this.
    only IAM Profile OIDC/PKCE tokens. Emitting SAML assertions to downstream
    applications is out of scope. Keycloak is not the primary user store
    (**supersedes D2**), not the PDP, and not a secret store.
-3. **Isolation.** Realms are the tenant boundary. The `tenant:platform` realm
+3. **Isolation tiers, with a defined upgrade path.** The realm is the tenant
-   is separate and reserved. A tenant without the `IAM` role gets a realm in
+   boundary and `tenant:platform` is a separate, reserved realm. Isolation is
-   the shared broker; a tenant with the `IAM` role gets a dedicated broker
+   a tenant-selectable tier, expected to be a paid upgrade:
-   instance (ADR-0014). A shared broker gives realm-level, not process-level,
+
-   isolation, so it is acceptable only for tenants whose federation trust and
+   | Tier | Name | Boundary | Selected by |
-   data classification allow that. Realm admins may not alter IAM Profile
+   | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-   semantics, the platform realm, federation trust settings, or audit
+   | `shared-realm` | Default | Own realm in the shared broker: realm-level isolation only (shared process, database and admin plane) | Default for any federated tenant |
-   retention. tenant-engine, not Keycloak, is the source of truth for tenant
+   | `dedicated-instance` | Upgrade | Own broker instance and database: process-level isolation, own scale and performance | Tenant acquires the `IAM` capability role (ADR-0014) |
-   existence and capability roles.
+
+   Realm admins in either tier may not alter IAM Profile semantics, the
+   platform realm, federation trust settings, or audit retention. Shared-realm
+   tenants must not be described as strongly isolated. tenant-engine owns
+   tenant existence, capability roles and plan; the tier is *derived* from
+   the `IAM` role, never stored as a second independent fact.
+
+   **Reference points that make the upgrade non-breaking.** These are
+   binding on implementation and documentation:
+
+   1. **Issuer invariance.** The tenant's issuer URL (host plus
+      `/realms/<tenant>`) is the same in both tiers. An upgrade moves the
+      routing behind the hostname (Traefik), not the issuer, so applications,
+      audiences and account bindings do not change. The realm name is
+      therefore chosen once, is immutable, and is derived from the tenant id.
+   2. **Subject preservation.** Keycloak-local user ids are the `sub`. Upgrade
+      migrates the realm with users and their original ids preserved, and
+      federated-identity links intact. A migration that changes any `sub`
+      fails the drill and is not permitted.
+   3. **Tier-neutral declaration.** Each tenant realm is declared in git as
+      sanitized realm configuration plus a small tenant manifest naming the
+      tenant id, realm name and issuer. The manifest carries no tier field; the
+      tier is derived from tenant-engine, and the same realm declaration
+      deploys to either tier.
+   4. **Owner-executed runbook and drill.** A documented
+      shared-to-dedicated procedure exists with a rehearsed drill before
+      any paid tier is offered: export, import into an isolated instance,
+      verify `sub` preservation and login, cut routing, keep the source
+      realm read-only for a retention window, then remove it. Rollback is
+      re-routing to the still-intact source realm until that window ends.
+   5. **Per-tier evidence.** Backup ownership, off-host custody and an
+      isolated restore proof are recorded per tier; the dedicated tier
+      has its own database consumer and OpenBao role.
+   6. **Billing is out of scope here.** Plan and pricing are tenant-engine
+      facts; this ADR only fixes the technical contract that the `IAM` role
+      selects. Downgrade is not defined and needs its own decision.
+
 4. **Coexistence.** Each tenant has exactly one active issuer at a time,
    recorded by tenant-engine and published as issuer configuration. KeyCape
    stays unchanged and keeps serving lightweight tenants. Applications target
@@ -84,7 +120,7 @@ of this.
   working tenants; contradicts capability-driven adoption.
 - **Dedicated instance for every federated tenant.** Strongest isolation, but on
   one node the cost is multiplied database, memory and patching for tenants
-  that do not need it. Kept for `IAM`-role tenants.
+  that do not need it. Offered as the paid `dedicated-instance` upgrade.
 - **Realm-per-tenant only, including `IAM` tenants.** Contradicts ADR-0014's
   meaning of `IAM`.
 - **Keycloak as SAML IdP downstream too.** No consumer requires it; widens the
@@ -101,6 +137,8 @@ of this.
 - tenant-engine needs an issuer-per-tenant field; this is a dependency to
   raise with its owner, not something built here.
 - Shared-broker realms cannot be described as strongly isolated tenants.
+- The upgrade constrains the design now: immutable realm names, issuer
+  hostnames that can be re-routed, and `sub`-preserving realm migration.
 - No HA is implied; T02 and T08 must name backup ownership, off-host custody
   and an isolated restore proof.
 

docs/platform-identity-security-architecture.md

@@ -137,7 +137,9 @@ required that the lightweight stack does not provide — chiefly inbound
 enterprise federation and SAML brokering (Entra ID, Active Directory,
 generic SAML IdPs), complex multi-realm topologies, or delegated admin.
 A deployment climbs to expanded mode because it needs that capability,
-not because it has more users. The lower resource and operational
+not because it has more users. Federated tenants start in a shared realm and
+can upgrade to a dedicated instance via the `IAM` capability role without
+changing issuer or subjects (ADR-0009, decision 3). The lower resource and operational
 footprint of the lightweight stack is a consequence of this rule, not the
 trigger for it. See **Capability Progression** below.
 

workplans/NK-WP-0011-enterprise-federation-saml.md

@@ -117,7 +117,7 @@ Out of scope:
 ```task
 id: NK-WP-0011-T01
 state_hub_task_id: "a5807808-fb34-50de-8f67-9128011833d4"
-status: progress
+status: done
 priority: high
 ```
 
@@ -251,8 +251,25 @@ audit sink alongside flex-auth/Topaz/OpenBao records, with correlation
 ids — satisfying the "Audit sink" and "Break-glass" rows of the
 production-readiness checklist.
 
+## Prove the isolation upgrade path
+
+```task
+id: NK-WP-0011-T09
+status: todo
+priority: medium
+```
+
+**Shared-realm to dedicated-instance upgrade (ADR-0009, decision 3).** Write
+the owner-executed upgrade runbook and rehearse it in an isolated environment
+before any paid tier is offered. The drill must show issuer URL unchanged,
+every user `sub` and federated link preserved, login working after cutover,
+rollback by re-routing during the retention window, and per-tier backup and
+restore evidence. Coordinate with tenant-engine on deriving the tier from the
+`IAM` capability role; do not add an independent tier field.
+
 ## Acceptance Criteria
 
+- A rehearsed shared-to-dedicated isolation upgrade preserves issuer and subjects.
 - An ADR records the expanded-mode trigger, federation topology,
   selected realm/tenant isolation model, and KeyCape/Keycloak issuer coexistence.
 - A federated user from at least one enterprise IdP (Entra ID) can log in