gate-house circulated v0.8 with two questions for this repository as owner of
the NetKingdom emission-cadence security profile: whether §17's ownership
paragraph reads in our own voice, and whether §11's new conformance item
follows the profile or diverges from it.
§17 is confirmed as written. It assigns the generic EmissionCadenceDeclaration
contract to info-tech-canon and to net-kingdom the MUST/SHOULD split, the
rare-class rate-monitoring prohibition, and the heartbeat-plus-reconciliation
obligation — which is emission-cadence-security-profile_v0.1.md §3, conjunction
included. No change.
§11 diverged in both directions and is corrected. Requiring a detection surface
of "heartbeat or reconciliation" of every load-bearing source withholds from a
volume class the expected-rate form the profile permits, and accepts for a rare
class either control alone where the profile — and the checker in
tools/emission-cadence-profile — require both. A rare class covered by a
heartbeat alone has no reconciliation to catch divergence, and one covered by
reconciliation alone produces no claim that can go missing, which is the whole
reason §9.6 rejects rate monitoring there. The item also contradicted its own
following paragraph, which admits rate monitoring except where the class is
rare.
The check now defers the form to the governing profile rather than restating a
split that is §17's to assign, carries the volume/rare distinction explicitly,
and states that classification is the source's published inventory and never the
checker's to infer from a name, payload, or observed rate — otherwise omission
detection is circular.
Change log item 6 and §14 record the review. The standard stays proposed;
publication and the acceptance flip wait on the close of the circulation round.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01Ek3zTdfMa35bPVDjVUyhxx
Assistant: claude-code
Assistant-Model: opus
Assistant-Process: 868701@bnt-lap001
Assistant-Session: b2e101b6-f501-40dc-9ee5-438cac36e21a
tegwick
da7747dc42