ops-warden/workplans/archived/260515-WARDEN-WP-0002-correctness-and-completeness.md

---
id: WARDEN-WP-0002
type: workplan
title: "OpsWarden Correctness and Operational Completeness"
domain: custodian
repo: ops-warden
status: archived
owner: Bernd
topic_slug: custodian
planning_priority: high
planning_order: 2
created: "2026-05-15"
updated: "2026-05-15"
state_hub_workstream_id: "5a9fba2c-6161-49a4-a231-e750fa4ab572"
---

> **Terminology note:** Historical text in this archived workplan may use the legacy term "workstream". The fleet term is **workplan** (`canon/standards/workplan-terminology-fleet_v0.1.md`).

# WARDEN-WP-0002 — Correctness and Operational Completeness

**Scope:** Fix three functional gaps identified after WARDEN-WP-0001: TTL max
enforcement (directive compliance), stale cert cleanup (SCOPE.md promises it),
and an outgoing signatures log (audit traceability for every signing operation).

**Out of scope:** Test coverage improvements (WARDEN-WP-0003), Vault cluster
setup, host-side principal deployment.

---

## Goal

After this workplan:

1. `warden sign` and `warden issue` reject TTLs that exceed the type maximum
   defined in the AccessManagementDirective — no cert can be silently issued
   with a longer-than-allowed validity window.
2. Stale/expired certs do not accumulate in the state dir. `warden cleanup`
   provides an on-demand sweep; `LocalCA.sign()` auto-evicts the previous cert
   for the same actor before writing the new one.
3. Every successful signing operation is recorded in an append-only
   `signatures.log` in the state dir. `warden log` provides a human-readable
   and machine-readable view of the signing history.

---

## Reference Documents

| Document | Location |
|---|---|
| AccessManagementDirective | `wiki/AccessManagementDirective.md` |
| WARDEN-WP-0001 | `workplans/WARDEN-WP-0001-initial-implementation.md` |
| SCOPE.md | `SCOPE.md` |

---

## Design Decisions

### TTL enforcement: reject, don't clamp

When `spec.ttl_hours > DEFAULT_TTL_HOURS[actor_type]`, raise `CAError` rather
than silently clamping. A silent clamp would mask configuration errors and hide
directive violations from operators. An explicit error forces a deliberate
decision.

The check lives in `CABackend.sign()` before the subprocess call so it applies
to both `LocalCA` and `VaultCA`. Vault's own role `max_ttl` provides a second
layer; this check is the warden-side gate.

### Cleanup: proactive (on sign) + reactive (on demand)

`LocalCA.sign()` removes the previous cert for the same actor before writing the
new one — this keeps state_dir from growing unboundedly under normal operation.
`warden cleanup` handles the edge cases: certs whose actor is no longer in the
inventory, certs from aborted sessions, certs left by actors that were renamed.

`VaultCA.sign()` also evicts before writing (same logic, same helper function).

### Signatures log: JSONL, append-only, in state_dir

One line per signing event, written after a successful `CertRecord` is produced.
Format: `{"timestamp": ..., "actor": ..., "actor_type": ..., "identity": ...,
"principals": [...], "ttl_hours": ..., "valid_before": ..., "backend": ...}`.

The log lives alongside certs in `state_dir` so a single directory backup
captures the full operational history. No rotation at this scope — add rotation
in a follow-up if the file grows beyond a few MB in practice.

`warden log` is read-only. No deletion via CLI — the log is an audit artefact.

---

## Tasks

### T1 — TTL max enforcement per ActorType

```task
id: WARDEN-WP-0002-T1
state_hub_task_id: b0d0b5f7-a181-4590-be26-c48ae28cd964
status: done
priority: high
```

- [x] `models.py`: add `MAX_TTL_HOURS = DEFAULT_TTL_HOURS` alias (same values,
      explicit name signals policy intent); add helper
      `enforce_ttl(spec: CertSpec) -> None` that raises `CAError` when
      `spec.ttl_hours > MAX_TTL_HOURS[spec.actor_type]`
- [x] `ca.py`: call `enforce_ttl(spec)` at the top of `CABackend.sign()` base
      (or in both `LocalCA.sign()` and `VaultCA.sign()` if no shared base call)
- [x] `scorecard.py`: add `check_ttl_policy(state_dir, inventory)` — parse each
      cert in state_dir via `ssh-keygen -L`; compare cert validity window
      duration against `MAX_TTL_HOURS[actor_type]`; flag if exceeded
- [x] Add `check_ttl_policy` to `run_scorecard()`
- [x] Update tests: `test_ca.py` — assert `CAError` raised when `ttl_hours`
      exceeds max for each type; assert no error at exactly the max

### T2 — Stale cert cleanup command

```task
id: WARDEN-WP-0002-T2
state_hub_task_id: aeeefbad-c0bd-4ae8-a3fe-9f72321b4caa
status: done
priority: medium
```

- [x] `ca.py`: extract `_evict_cert(actor_name, state_dir)` — removes
      `state_dir/<actor_name>-cert.pub` if it exists; call at the top of
      `LocalCA.sign()` and `VaultCA.sign()` before writing the new cert
- [x] `cli.py`: add `warden cleanup [actor-name]` command
      - No actor-name: iterate `state_dir/*.cert.pub`, remove any whose
        `valid_before < now - 5 min`
      - With actor-name: remove only that actor's cert if stale
      - `--dry-run`: print what would be removed without deleting
      - Exit 0 always (cleanup is idempotent; nothing to clean is not an error)
- [x] Update `check_no_stale_certs` scorecard check detail message to suggest
      running `warden cleanup`
- [x] Update tests: verify `_evict_cert` is called during sign; verify cleanup
      command removes stale file; verify `--dry-run` does not delete

### T3 — Outgoing signatures log

```task
id: WARDEN-WP-0002-T3
state_hub_task_id: 0194d24f-a8fe-4f6d-88e6-addea3542c0e
status: done
priority: medium
```

- [x] `ca.py`: after a successful `CertRecord` is produced in `LocalCA.sign()`
      and `VaultCA.sign()`, call `_append_signature_log(record, spec, state_dir,
      backend)` which appends a JSONL line to
      `state_dir/signatures.log`
      Fields: `timestamp` (ISO 8601 UTC), `actor`, `actor_type`, `identity`,
      `principals`, `ttl_hours`, `valid_before`, `cert_path`, `backend`
- [x] `cli.py`: add `warden log [actor-name]` command
      - Reads `state_dir/signatures.log` (empty list if absent)
      - `--last N` (default 20): show last N entries
      - `--actor <name>`: filter by actor
      - `--json`: output newline-delimited JSON; default: Rich table
      - Exit 0 always
- [x] Update tests: verify log entry written after sign; verify log not written
      on CAError; verify `warden log` filters correctly

---

## Acceptance Criteria

- [x] `warden sign agt-test --pubkey /tmp/k.pub --ttl 100` raises `CAError`
      (agt max is 24h)
- [x] `warden sign agt-test --pubkey /tmp/k.pub --ttl 24` succeeds
- [x] `warden scorecard` includes TTL policy check; fails when a cert exceeds type max
- [x] After `warden sign`, `state_dir/signatures.log` has one new line; valid JSON
- [x] `warden log` renders a table; `warden log --json` is parseable
- [x] `warden log --actor agt-test` returns only entries for that actor
- [x] `warden cleanup --dry-run` lists stale certs without deleting
- [x] `warden cleanup` removes stale certs; scorecard `no_stale_certs` passes after
- [x] Re-signing an actor replaces its cert file (no accumulation)
- [x] All tests pass: `uv run pytest`
- [x] All lints pass: `uv run ruff check .`