# ADR conflict pass (WP-0003-T03)

Kinds 1–4 and 6. Kind 5 waits on the estate arc42 chapter 9. Rulings
live in `rulings.json` and survive a ledger refresh.

## How kind 1 is treated

A shared **front-matter `id`** (`ADR-001` in four repos, `ADR-0001` in
three, `netkingdom-iam-profile` on two files) cannot appear twice in
`publication.json`. That is a prefix/rename packet, not a contradiction
of decisions. The ledger records kind `1` automatically. Disposition
stays `publish` or `unreviewed` unless another kind applies.

Bare `ADR-NNNN` in many filenames is expected. It is not kind 1.

## Kind 2 — status lie

| Source | What the files say | Who rules |
| --- | --- | --- |
| `net-kingdom/canon/standards/iam-profile_v0.2.md` | Front-matter `accepted`. v0.3 says it supersedes v0.2. | net-kingdom |
| `railiance-hosts` and `railiance-infra` `ADR-002` | Body **Status: Superseded by ADR-003**. No YAML `status`. | those repos |
| `coulomb-social/docs/adr/ADR-0002-…` | Status is **superseded in part** by ADR-0003/0004. | coulomb-social |

Mentions of “supersedes” meaning *this* ADR replaces an older one (flex-auth
0003, artifact-store 0001, glas-harness 001) are not status lies.

## Kind 3 — missing / stale successor

| Source | Gap | Who rules |
| --- | --- | --- |
| `the-custodian/canon/standards/iam-profile_v0.1.md` | `superseded_by` still names v0.2; current is v0.3. | the-custodian |

Custodian ADR-008 already names Tenancy Posture. No gap.

## Kind 4 — contradicting decisions

No pair of *accepted* ADRs was found that cannot both be true.
railiance-platform ADR-0003 restates custodian ADR-001 (hub is a read
model). That is alignment, not a clash.

## Kind 6 — duplicate current claim

| Sources | Claim | Who rules |
| --- | --- | --- |
| custodian ADR-008 vs Tenancy Posture | Multi-tenancy framework. ADR-008 is already superseded. T04: `superseded`. | already ruled in the source |
| iam-profile v0.2 and v0.3 | Same `id`, both `accepted`. T04: v0.2 `superseded`, v0.3 `publish` after id fix. | net-kingdom |
| railiance-hosts and railiance-infra ADR-002 | Identical superseded copies. | those repos (historical only) |
| railiance-hosts and railiance-infra ADR-003 | Identical **accepted** 5-repo stack ADR. **Conflict.** | those repos or railiance-master |
| railiance-hosts and railiance-infra ADR-004 | Identical **accepted** Forgejo runner ADR. **Conflict.** | those repos |

## Conflict rows that stay unpublished

Until the owner rules:

1. `railiance-hosts` / `railiance-infra` ADR-003
2. `railiance-hosts` / `railiance-infra` ADR-004
3. `coulomb-social` ADR-0002 (partial supersession)

Kind 5 (architecture miss) is not run yet. It starts when
`coulomb-estate_v0.1.md` chapter 9 exists.
