INTENT: the register is no longer empty, and the first finding tested the deferral

Controlled disclosure was deferred to production on the reasoning that build
mode has no users to expose. The first finding to arrive is a live
authorization bypass in the service every other service trusts, where the
choice today is publish or hold with nothing between. The deferral may still be
right; it is now a decision with a real case in hand.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
This commit is contained in:
tegwick 2026-08-17 22:52:37 +02:00
parent 97762a4be0
commit 38e083ed3d

View file

@ -100,10 +100,22 @@ directly. Like that repo, it is downstream by construction and must not become
a second source of truth — a finding is a claim about a system, and the system
remains authoritative about itself.
The first content is already waiting: the unverified tenant boundary, the
absent noisy-neighbour characterisation, the missing quality-of-service
vocabulary, and the erasure-versus-audit tension — all currently open questions
in NetKingdom's *Tenancy Posture* standard, which is a draft and not a register.
The register is no longer empty. `RISK-F-0001` arrived on 2026-08-17: a live
authorization bypass in `flex-auth`, self-reported during a framework review.
Three more defects surfaced in the same round and are recorded inside it as
visible-but-unfiled, pending this repo setting the precedent for what warrants
a record of its own.
**The first finding already tested the deferral.** Controlled disclosure is
recorded above as deferred to production, on the reasoning that build mode has
no users to expose. `RISK-F-0001` is a live authorization bypass in the service
every other service trusts, and today the choice is publish or hold with
nothing in between. That may still be the right deferral — but it is now a
decision taken with a real case in hand rather than a hypothetical one.
Also waiting: the unverified tenant boundary, the absent noisy-neighbour
characterisation, and the erasure-versus-audit tension — open questions in
NetKingdom's *Tenancy Posture*, which is a draft and not a register.
## What good looks like