Complete Phase V Spirits and Ghosts (SOUL-WP-0006)

Formalize Sp. evaluation dimensions and Gh. authority/governance; map law gaps
without legal conclusions; support H9/H10; confirm TE-07. Write phase-v
synthesis, finish SOUL-WP-0006, and mark SOUL-WP-0007 ready.

concepts/spirit.md

@@ -1,28 +1,50 @@
 # Spirit (`Sp.`)
 
-**Status:** provisional  
-**See also:** H9, H10, RQ8, TE-07
+**Status:** revised (Phase V, 2026-08-12)  
+**See also:** H9, H10, RQ8, TE-07, `research/spirits/spirit-criteria-map.md`
 
 ## Working definition
 
-A **Spirit** is an artificial character derived through reflection on a known
-historical, contemporary, or fictional personality.
+A **Spirit** is an artificial character primarily derived through reflection on a
+known historical, contemporary, or fictional personality, typically from
+**publicly legitimate** sources.
 
-Designation example: **Albert Einstein Sp.**
+Designation: **`Albert Einstein Sp.`**
 
-Defining question: **How might an entity inspired by this personality behave and
-understand?**
+> How might an entity *inspired by* this personality behave and understand?
 
-Typically grounded in publicly legitimate cultural and historical information.
+**Not** a claim of identity with the source. Provenance = inspiration, not continuity.
 
-## Evaluation dimensions (candidates)
+## Spec vs instantiation vs Being
 
-- evidential grounding
-- interpretative transparency
-- source provenance
-- historical fidelity
-- uncertainty representation
-- behavioral plausibility
-- avoidance of false attribution
+| Stage | Status |
+|---|---|
+| Specification | Character/provenance package |
+| Instantiation | Running APE / process |
+| Spirit-Being | Only if Beinghood layers met |
 
-A Spirit remains an interpretation; `Sp.` marks that status explicitly.
+Lineage of the Spirit-being **begins at instantiation**.
+
+## Evaluation dimensions (S1–S10)
+
+| ID | Dimension |
+|---|---|
+| S1 | Evidential grounding |
+| S2 | Interpretative transparency |
+| S3 | Source provenance |
+| S4 | Historical/fictional fidelity |
+| S5 | Uncertainty representation |
+| S6 | Behavioral plausibility |
+| S7 | False-attribution avoidance (`Sp.` label) |
+| S8 | Scope discipline / counterfactual marking |
+| S9 | Relational reconstruction honesty (public only) |
+| S10 | Lineage honesty (own history after start) |
+
+## vs Ghost
+
+Public reflection vs **authority** over private/relational identity materials.
+See `concepts/ghost.md`.
+
+## Sources
+
+Introduction §9; RN-004/005; spirit-criteria-map; Phase V synthesis.