coulomb/soul-frame
4
0
Fork 0
Code Issues Pull requests Projects Releases Packages Wiki Activity Actions

Complete Phase II interaction (SOUL-WP-0003)

Browse source 
Map model-based mind, co-adaptive social cognition, and recognition/social
Beinghood into instruments and workstream notes. Support H3/H4/H7, judge TE-09,
write phase-ii-interaction-synthesis.md, finish SOUL-WP-0003, and mark
SOUL-WP-0004 ready.
This commit is contained in:
tegwick 2026-08-12 01:21:49 +02:00
parent cb40f77e5a
commit 807d6b17f6
15 changed files with 772 additions and 81 deletions
Download patch file Download diff file Expand all files Collapse all files

51
concepts/recognition.md
View file

@ -1,33 +1,50 @@
# Recognition
**Status:** revised (Phase I, 2026-08-12)
**See also:** H7, RQ6, TE-09, RN-001 Findings 8–10
**Status:** revised (Phase II, 2026-08-12)
**See also:** H7, RQ6, TE-09, `research/sociology/recognition-and-social-beinghood.md`
## Three senses
| Sense | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Epistemic | Detect/classify an entity |
| Intentional | Treat as agent with goals/beliefs (cf. intentional stance) |
| Social / normative | Treat as counterpart in relationships, obligations, reputation |
| Sense | Meaning | Adjacent work |
|---|---|---|
| **Epistemic** | Identify/track as the same entity | reidentification, addressability |
| **Intentional** | Treat as agent with goals/beliefs | Dennett intentional stance; Theory of Mind |
| **Social / normative** | Standing, perspective, claims matter among us | Honneth recognition theory; Mead; trust/reputation |
Do not collapse these senses.
## Layer model
```text
Autonomous individuality → may exist unrecognized
Intentional recognition → treated as agent-like
Addressability → can be specifically targeted
Social Beinghood → persistent reciprocal models, relations,
expectations, commitments, reputation
```
## Role in Beinghood
Recognition is **constitutive of social Beinghood**, not of bare autonomous
individuality. Beinghood v0.2 includes recognition among requirement families
for the intended “someone” category — TE-09 still pressures that packaging.
| Level | Role of recognition |
|---|---|
| Autonomous individuality | **not required** |
| Social Beinghood | **constitutive** (H7) |
| Soul Frame “Being” as *someone another can know* | recognition + personhood + addressability on autonomous base (Beinghood v0.2), with TE-09 pressure |
**Caution:** intentional recognition **over-generates** (APE false positives).
Recognition alone does not create systemic individuality (RN-001 Finding 10).
## Working social principle
> A system becomes socially relevant as a Being when other beings can distinguish
> it, address it, expect continuity from it, maintain models of it, and enter
> persistent relationships with it.
> A system becomes **socially** relevant as a Being when other beings can
> distinguish it, address it, expect continuity from it, maintain models of it,
> and enter persistent relationships with it.
## Related
## TE-09 (summary)
- **Addressability** — ability to target the entity specifically
- **Social Being** — embedded in reciprocal models and relations
Unrecognized coherent intelligence can be an autonomous individual without
Social Beinghood. See sociology map for full judgment.
## Sources
RN-001 §9–10; Mead 1934; Phase II sociology pass pending
RN-001 §9–10; Mead; Dennett; Honneth; Phase II sociology map; RN-006 (mutual models)