# Support / challenge matrix

**Paper:**  
**Status:** draft

| # | Paper claim (short) | Soul Frame concept(s) | Verdict | Rationale | Instrument follow-up |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | | | SUPPORT / CHALLENGE / EXTEND / ORTHOGONAL / UNCLEAR | | |

## Verdict legend

| Verdict | Meaning |
|---|---|
| SUPPORT | Strengthens an existing Soul Frame claim or definition |
| CHALLENGE | Pressures revision, split, rename, or abandonment |
| EXTEND | Adds a useful distinction Soul Frame lacked |
| ORTHOGONAL | Interesting but outside current Soul Frame scope |
| UNCLEAR | Needs rereading or secondary sources |