Adds specs/TargetRevenueCommercialUseAgreement-V1C1.md, the companion
agreement the License repeatedly refers to but never itself set terms
for: commercial entitlement grant, fees and explicit Development Credit
allocation, applicable monetization extensions, metering, audit rights,
term/termination (cross-referenced to License §7.2/§5.2 so a Commercial
Use Agreement termination can never revoke an already-converted Milestone
Release), and a real Section 9 implementing the informed-consent breach-
disclosure election that License §7.4 deferred here: opt-in named
disclosure vs. an anonymized default, a 10-business-day pre-publication
notice with a dispute window, and a data-protection carve-out.
Unlike the License, this Agreement had no dedicated prior-art research
pass (WP-0001 T01-T05 covered license models, terminology, patents,
contributor rights, and jurisdiction constraints, not commercial-agreement
drafting norms) — its preliminary notice says so explicitly, and Appendix A
leaves Section 13 (Indemnification) unwritten rather than guess at a
default carrying real financial exposure.
Corrects three prior references from the placeholder filename
"TRSL-CommercialUseAgreement-Draft.md" to the actual deliverable name, and
cross-references it from README, PRD, TSD, and SCOPE.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Revises V1C1 §7.4 per maintainer instruction: the License no longer sets a
named-by-default disclosure rule for published breach/termination records.
Instead, whether a Commercial Entitlement holder is named is governed
exclusively by the applicable Commercial Use Agreement — a bilaterally
negotiated contract where informed consent can actually be obtained. The
License itself only guarantees an anonymized Phase-and-category fallback
where no Commercial Use Agreement addresses it or none exists (e.g. a
noncommercial Section 2(c) breach).
This meaningfully reduces the License text's own legal exposure: the open
item is no longer "should the License name parties by default" but
"the not-yet-drafted Commercial Use Agreement template needs its own
naming/consent/data-protection clause" — recommended as a future
TRSL-CommercialUseAgreement-Draft.md deliverable, analogous to the CLA
recommendation already on record.
Updates Appendix A item 10, OpenQuestions-WorkingDefaults.md Q12 item 5,
PRD FR-10, and TSD §4.1 to match.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Per maintainer request after reviewing V1C1: breaches and their resolution
are transparently published via the Trust Service, giving the ecosystem a
conformity signal and creating reputational pressure toward compliance
alongside the existing commercial remedies.
- V1C1 §7.4 (new): Trust Service publishes the Licensor's breach notices,
cure status, and termination determinations per Phase, distinguishing
"alleged" from "determined" — a ministerial recording act, not a new
discretionary authority (consistent with §5.4's evidence-not-cause
principle). Named-by-default disclosure is the intended mechanism (the
deterrent only works if the party is identifiable), flagged in Appendix A
item 10 as the single most legally sensitive addition in this candidate:
it touches Commercial Use Agreement confidentiality, defamation law, and
data-protection law where the affected party is an individual.
- TSD §4.1: new Breach/Compliance Record Trust Service component, noted as
license-driven and deferred to a future Trust Service PRD rather than
retrofitted into WP-0002's already-finished Stage 0 scope.
- OpenQuestions-WorkingDefaults.md Q12: records the adopted default (publish
alleged/determined breach status) and the still-open naming-policy question.
- PRD FR-10: cross-references the new public record without resolving the
naming question.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Persists the five prior-art/legal research artifacts and the original
draft skeleton as dated history/ records (260729- prefix, git mv to
preserve history), consistent with this repo's convention that history/
holds dated non-normative artifacts rather than living working documents:
- history/260729-TRSL-PriorArt-Survey.md
- history/260729-TRSL-Terminology-Guardrails.md
- history/260729-TRSL-FutureLicense-PatentPrecedent.md
- history/260729-TRSL-ContributorRights-Research.md
- history/260729-TRSL-Jurisdiction-StandardTerms.md
- history/260729-TargetRevenueSourceLicense-Draft.md (superseded)
Adds specs/TargetRevenueSourceLicense-V1C1.md: the first candidate written
as actual operative license text (11 sections: definitions, noncommercial
grant, commercial-use restriction, patent license, automatic conversion,
successive phases, termination/cure, warranty/liability, trademarks,
general provisions) rather than a bracket-annotated skeleton. Carries a
prominent preliminary-status notice near the top and a non-normative
Appendix A tracking the nine items still needing legal resolution before
any candidate can become official Version 1.0.
Updates all cross-references (README, PRD, TSD, SCOPE, workplan) to the
new paths; the workplan's T06 human-accept gate now points at V1C1.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Moves TargetRevenueLicenseConcept.md from the separate singular spec/
directory into specs/ (git mv, preserving history) and updates every live
cross-reference (README, CONTRIBUTING, all specs/*.md, workplans, schema
comments, source docstrings, test file) to the new path.
This resolves the spec/ vs specs/ split that history/260728-SWOT-Assessment.md
flagged as a "perpetual footgun" and recommended deciding on. The historical
record of that split and the recommendation itself are left unedited in
history/ (a dated assessment, not a living document) — only README and TSD
now document the merge as resolved, with a pointer back to that history file
for context.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Resolves the WP-0003-T06 review flag: the single administrative-correction
ledger entry type had an unstated fold-side effect (concept §17 names the
type but never says which side of the target it corrects). Maintainer chose
option (a) — split into administrative-correction-development and
administrative-correction-remission so the corrected side is explicit in
the type name rather than an implicit library default.
- schemas/ledger_entry.schema.json: enum split, no other behavior change.
- src/target_revenue/fold.py: each new type maps to its named side only.
- specs/TargetLedgerSpecification.md, TechnicalSpecificationDocument.md
§3.2, ProductRequirementsDocument.md FR-5: updated to the split types.
- tests/test_ledger_fold.py: dedicated coverage for both new types plus a
regression test that the old unsplit type name is now rejected.
spec/TargetRevenueLicenseConcept.md §17 is left unedited — its entry-type
list is explicitly non-exhaustive ("may include"), so this specializes
rather than contradicts it.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Stabilizes day-to-day terminology out of the exploratory concept draft:
- specs/TargetRevenueFrameworkCore.md — core terms, target formula,
five-verb lifecycle, nine rules, invariants.
- specs/PhaseManifestSpecification.md — field tiers aligned with
schemas/phase_manifest.schema.json.
- specs/TargetLedgerSpecification.md — entry types, hash chain, pure
Outstanding Target fold, aligned with the WP-0002 library.
- specs/MonetizationExtensionSpecification.md — six-field contract,
registered/canonical distinction, Stage 0 Q11 catalog.
Cross-links PRD/TSD/README/CONTRIBUTING to the new extracts, confirms no
placeholder tails remain, and prepares a review checklist for T06 (human
promotion gate, left open pending maintainer review).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Introduce SCOPE, expanded README, CONTRIBUTING, and provisional open-question
defaults. Rescope Trust Service work to offline schemas/fold/fixtures, add
normative core extraction workplan, and split PRD roadmap Phase 4 into
foundation vs hosted service. Sync workplans with State Hub.
Establishes specs/ProductRequirementsDocument.md and
specs/TechnicalSpecificationDocument.md, plus two workplans: prior-art
research for the TargetRevenueSourceLicense draft, and bootstrapping the
Trust Service reference implementation.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
