one clause short
Nine decisions. Two were not on T03's list; both are the review's.
D2: specs/GroundRules.md §Underdetermined IS the register. C4 pointed out
it was never evaluated as a candidate, and against the survey's own five
benchmarks it already delivers four -- including the Magic Oracle property
("a ruling flips the scenario, not the kernel", :231-233) that the survey
travelled to Magic to discover and we had written down ourselves eight
days earlier. What it lacks is reproductions. So this pass extends a
section rather than building a register: no new file, no new schema, and
no second mechanism to disagree with the first.
D3: admissibility is three clauses. It exists; it has the ruled shape
(GROUND-WP-0004 T02's row-level table, never a sum -- promoted from a T04
addendum because two of three wrong premises were sums without tables);
and it CAN FAIL. The third is C1's. GR-E01's scenario went green when the
edition landed, and the finding stayed admissible and stayed queued for
transmission, because nothing in the rule said a passing artifact was a
signal. A green reproduction is an alarm, not a reassurance.
D1 applied: INTENT gains a fourth property, Instrument, worded as a
mechanism rather than an ambition and carrying its own falsifier -- if a
pass tolerates an undecided rule by quietly picking a default, the
property is false.
D4 five kinds, each forced by an existing finding; a sixth during backfill
means the taxonomy was invented. D5 lifecycle where `applied` means the
source changed, the queue empties while the log accumulates, and
withdrawals are reported rather than deleted -- GR-E01 is why. D6 notes
admitted but never reportable, 30-day expiry on the existing age
machinery; refusing them would discard the only class of finding the
engine cannot produce itself, which is CB-WP-0025's whole input. D7 no
engine-evolution register, on an inventory C5 corrected -- narrowed, not
settled. D8 design-baseline.py retired, kept as a dated snapshot because
deleting it erases the evidence for how 33% got in. D9 the artifact stays
here, ground-game gets a generated file under its own workplan.
loop-lint: no findings. facts-check: no findings.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
tegwick
580081ef71