tegwick
53bb65e7a6
Assistant: codex Assistant-Model: gpt-6-astra Assistant-Session: 01a0e241-8285-7a63-8c0c-51c9cb824dc3
2.5 KiB
Source readiness for the 0.1 research preview
Reviewed 2026-09-27 by Codex, author-model editorial review. Inputs: source reviews
and receipts committed through 8cc7016; no new external verification. Owner:
WP-0002 T02. Review scope is traceability and qualified interpretation, not full
implementation validation or currency of living documentation.
| Criterion | Disposition | Evidence / remaining boundary |
|---|---|---|
| Identifiable first source and claim locators | pass | Carniato review, SRC-0001/C01–C03; edition/date uncertainty remains explicit |
| Independently sourced local-first contrast | pass | Local-first review, SRC-0002/C01–C03; primary local record is distinct from globally valid transaction |
| Source claims versus our interpretations | pass | Both claim tables separate these; AuthorityPilot records conditional authority and acknowledgement decisions |
| Extensions with traceable limits and counterexamples | pass | E01–E12, T01–T05, R01–R06; living docs and partial source uses are qualified |
| Generated output screened and failures retained | pass | Failed/truncated runs and invalid edges remain in receipts/reviews; extracted model text is not automatically admitted |
| Current public maturity claims | pass for preview scope | README and release entry describe seventeen hypotheses, partial evidence and unproved usefulness |
| Actual storage atomicity, receiver semantics and full-contract independent uses | defer | These exceed the original two-source review deliverable; explicit residual ownership below |
| Independent human/AT usefulness | defer | WP-0002 T03 / WP-0003 T02 retain these gates; submitted model review does not meet them |
Disposition: the original WP-0002 T02 source-review deliverable is complete at this bounded documentary level. Earlier notes accumulated implementation and fault validation obligations; completion here does not erase them. Transfer those obligations to WP-0003 T04 (origin WP-0002 T02), alongside existing T01 source comparison work. WP-0002 itself stays active and M1 remains revise/defer under T03.
The dated source reviews retain their original extracted status as historical records; their appended editorial-assessment links identify this later disposition without rewriting the original source collection or claiming revalidation of external content.