frontend-patterns/research/reviews/LooseEnds-2026-09-28.md
tegwick 9baf6f1829 Complete bounded recovery checks and reconcile blocked workplans
Assistant: codex
Assistant-Model: gpt-6-astra
Assistant-Session: 01a0e738-9e15-7600-87e6-90dec3a7beef
2026-09-28 11:06:35 +02:00

3.7 KiB

Loose-end review — 2026-09-28

Reviewed all eight local workplans, including finished records. Initially WP-0006 was active; WP-0002/0003/0004/0008 blocked; WP-0001/0005/0007 finished. No ready or proposed workplan remained. Working tree was clean. State Hub inbox and FEP human- needed task results were empty; source files take precedence over the stale brief.

Existing task(s) Closeout disposition Remaining prerequisite / resume condition
WP-0003 T04 Done: implemented and executed the preregistered concrete SQLite/Git recovery experiment; nine checks, including two negative controls Bounded evidence and exclusions; no stronger frontend/durability claim
WP-0002 T03 Wait; plan blocked Independent usefulness/validated seed-case evidence; submitted model worksheet is not independent human review
WP-0003 T01 Progress; plan remains blocked by T02 Six-stream full-contract implementation evidence remains incomplete. Static source paths, authored fixtures and documentary leads are not independent full uses; existing navigation fixture remains paused
WP-0003 T02 Wait; plan blocked M1 acceptance, then completed contrasting cases and quality/human/AT evidence
WP-0004 T01 Wait; plan blocked M1 acceptance before canonical validator/export
WP-0004 T02/T03 Wait; plan blocked M2 acceptance before held-out evaluation and complete real-repository applicability studies
WP-0006 T03 Changed to wait; plan changed to blocked Useful comparable research window; largest group has two cycles and incomplete effort. Today's different runtime protocol cannot make three
WP-0008 T01 Wait; plan blocked Hosted discovery/common-template integration and first real pinned consumer decision
WP-0008 T02 Wait; plan blocked Actual consumer closeout hook, real use and linked observed outcome; roster still empty
WP-0008 T03 Wait; plan blocked Admitted budget-enforced executor, standing release/rollback evidence, natural cadence proof and a real unassisted cycle/monthly packet

Other tasks remain done. No task or workplan was created or cancelled; no evidence gate was waived. No finished workplan was reopened. WP-0003 T01 remains actionable research, not an invented external blocker; completing its broad independent-use contract cannot be substituted by further author-only synthesis in this closeout. WP-0006 waits on a qualifying evidence window rather than running repetitions for a count. Existing tasks retain all obligations; no residual work is parked here alone.

The WP-0008 recheck found only September 27 intake smoke/manual receipts, not the expected September 28 natural daily receipt. Query evidence records absence without diagnosing the scheduler. The owner plans ACTIVITY-WP-0041 and GLAS-WP-0012 remain blocked; this session grants no runtime authority. The October 1 packet remains due even without consumers. No schedule or service changed.

Current profiles and evolution reporting now include the bounded recovery evidence; all eighteen candidates remain hypotheses. Current orientation counts are corrected; frozen seventeen-record 0.1 publication and historical reviews remain immutable.

Validation also exposed a pre-existing missing CAND-0018 classification record. Completed that local T01 repair after reading the candidate: composition/portability with implementation and compatibility costs. No new pattern or maturity change. Checks: 69 tests passed across evolution, schema, bench/admission and reference; synthetic bench plan, evolution/reference/classification freshness and whitespace. The classification failure before repair is recorded here rather than hidden.