tegwick 0a1d1d942a Rule INFD-IN-0001: PEP-shaped, presentation claim permitted, view_hash distinct

informed-decision filed three rulings before writing any architecture,
with candidate answers, their costs, the self-dealing objection argued
against itself, and a list of what it was not asking for. That order is
what section 17 exists to produce, and KEY-WP-0013-T02 is blocked today,
so it is answered now rather than queued.

R1 — PEP-shaped, confirmed as proposed, not an Engine. It holds no
state another layer reads at runtime for a verdict, which is the test.
Its layer stays its own to declare; this settles its shape, which is
what was blocking. It should build to v0.8's obligation 3 rather than
v0.7's and inherit GH-DEC-2026-010's attribution gap knowingly rather
than describe its validation as complete.

R2 — yes, and no second catalog row. PEP and PIP are shapes a
repository has; the catalog records layers it occupies. Obligation 5
forbids a PIP republishing the PDP's decision, which is a prohibition
on republishing a decision, not on holding two shapes. Three limits
carry the permission: the claim carries presentation and nothing else,
it must never be an input to the decision it presents for, and its
evidence copy reaches audit-core independently of the emitter. The last
is the one that matters here, because the actor and the source are the
same component.

R3 — candidate (b). The binding digest is authoritative for what the
request is; view_hash only for what was shown; a disagreement between
them is a finding against the presenting surface, never a fact about
the request. (a) is refused doctrinally rather than on the cost given:
merging the two makes one repository the authority on what another
layer computes over a request, which is GH-DEC-2026-008's objection to
translation. (c) is refused because nesting the binding digest inside
view_hash reproduces the hash cycle that made GH-DEC-2026-008
unimplementable — we paid for that lesson once this quarter. The two
link by co-reference instead: the presentation record names the binding
identifier and never recomputes the other layer's digest.

The residual is not closed and the ruling says so, as they asked. A
compromised surface can present X and attest Y. Attestation covers
accident and later tampering, never a compromised source — the same
disposition approval-engine's equivalent takes.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_012viPor8WJNCbV64ipwewrm

Assistant: claude-code
Assistant-Model: opus
Assistant-Process: 1754332@bnt-lap001
Assistant-Session: 9c8ac536-ff5e-46a3-8ab1-a548bde25fc0

2026-09-09 22:10:45 +02:00

3.4 KiB

Raw Blame History

Work Records — gate-house

Generated by statehub fix-consistency (CUST-WP-0061-T04, work-record stage 3). Do not edit by hand — edit the source file/block listed for each record and re-run fix-consistency to refresh this index. Archived workplans are omitted; closed decisions/intakes/engagements stay listed so recently-resolved work is still visible. [auto]

Kind	ID	Status	Lane	Source
workplan	GH-WP-0001	finished	—	workplans/GH-WP-0001-foundation.md
workplan	GH-WP-0002	finished	—	workplans/GH-WP-0002-approval-evidence-integrity.md
workplan	GH-WP-0003	finished	—	workplans/GH-WP-0003-statute-v08-amendment-set.md
task	GH-WP-0001-T01	done	—	workplans/GH-WP-0001-foundation.md
task	GH-WP-0001-T02	done	—	workplans/GH-WP-0001-foundation.md
task	GH-WP-0001-T03	done	—	workplans/GH-WP-0001-foundation.md
task	GH-WP-0001-T04	done	—	workplans/GH-WP-0001-foundation.md
task	GH-WP-0001-T05	done	—	workplans/GH-WP-0001-foundation.md
task	GH-WP-0001-T06	done	—	workplans/GH-WP-0001-foundation.md
task	GH-WP-0002-T01	done	—	workplans/GH-WP-0002-approval-evidence-integrity.md
task	GH-WP-0002-T02	done	—	workplans/GH-WP-0002-approval-evidence-integrity.md
task	GH-WP-0002-T03	done	—	workplans/GH-WP-0002-approval-evidence-integrity.md
task	GH-WP-0002-T04	done	—	workplans/GH-WP-0002-approval-evidence-integrity.md
task	GH-WP-0002-T05	done	—	workplans/GH-WP-0002-approval-evidence-integrity.md
task	GH-WP-0002-T06	done	—	workplans/GH-WP-0002-approval-evidence-integrity.md
task	GH-WP-0003-T01	done	—	workplans/GH-WP-0003-statute-v08-amendment-set.md
task	GH-WP-0003-T02	done	—	workplans/GH-WP-0003-statute-v08-amendment-set.md
task	GH-WP-0003-T03	done	—	workplans/GH-WP-0003-statute-v08-amendment-set.md
task	GH-WP-0003-T04	done	—	workplans/GH-WP-0003-statute-v08-amendment-set.md
task	GH-WP-0003-T05	done	—	workplans/GH-WP-0003-statute-v08-amendment-set.md
task	GH-WP-0003-T06	done	—	workplans/GH-WP-0003-statute-v08-amendment-set.md
task	GH-WP-0003-T07	done	—	workplans/GH-WP-0003-statute-v08-amendment-set.md
task	GH-WP-0003-T08	done	—	workplans/GH-WP-0003-statute-v08-amendment-set.md
task	GH-WP-0003-T09	done	—	workplans/GH-WP-0003-statute-v08-amendment-set.md
intake	GH-IN-0001	closed	red	intakes/intakes.md
intake	GH-IN-0002	closed	red	intakes/intakes.md
decision	GH-DEC-2026-001	resolved	—	decisions/decisions.md
decision	GH-DEC-2026-002	resolved	—	decisions/decisions.md
decision	GH-DEC-2026-003	resolved	—	decisions/decisions.md
decision	GH-DEC-2026-004	resolved	—	decisions/decisions.md
decision	GH-DEC-2026-005	resolved	—	decisions/decisions.md
decision	GH-DEC-2026-006	resolved	—	decisions/decisions.md
decision	GH-DEC-2026-007	resolved	—	decisions/decisions.md
decision	GH-DEC-2026-008	resolved	—	decisions/decisions.md
decision	GH-DEC-2026-009	resolved	—	decisions/decisions.md
decision	GH-DEC-2026-010	resolved	—	decisions/decisions.md
decision	GH-DEC-2026-011	resolved	—	decisions/decisions.md

3.4 KiB Raw Blame History

Work Records — gate-house

3.4 KiB

Raw Blame History