key-cape/docs/approval-engine-auth-contract.md
tegwick dcebd46fa6
All checks were successful
Build and Publish Container Image / build-and-push (push) Successful in 40s
Require typed issuer refusals in live registration verification
Assistant: codex
Assistant-Model: gpt-5.6-luna
Assistant-Session: 01a07ff8-19d0-7820-b4d0-1353833cb7fc
2026-09-08 16:46:02 +02:00

2.6 KiB

Approval-engine token contract

Static client registrations may set audience: approval-engine. This selects only the access-token audience; OIDC ID tokens retain aud=clientId. Omitting audience preserves the existing client-ID access audience, including OpenBao consumers. Request audience and resource parameters cannot override it. Access tokens contain the granted scope string for both supported grant types.

config/service-clients.example.yaml provides the two requested confidential clients: secrets-engine-approval gets read/consume, and approval-engine-operator gets lifecycle/observation scopes without consume. Service tokens contain principal_type=service, tenant, roles, scope, assurance, issuer, subject, audience, issue time and expiry; the lifetime is 15 minutes. The issuer signs with RS256 and publishes its public key through /jwks.

Human approvers need a separate authorization-code/PKCE registration with an exact deployment-owned callback, audience: approval-engine, allowedScopes: [openid, approval:approve], and mfaRequired: true. Do not add consume or other approval grants to that client. No callback is invented here. The ID token is for the login client; present the access token to approval-engine.

These fragments are not live registrations. The two service registrations require custody-managed values for the named environment references and a reviewed rollout of this version, including the upstream issuer precondition. Platform's CCR-2026-0017/0018 use OpenBao field CLIENT_SECRET; their approval remains open. The separate human registration needs its actual UI-owned callback. A bearer-only approval resource server has no such callback; its absence does not prevent service-client issuance or service startup, and service credentials cannot be counted as human approval evidence. Never log the token or secret. Verify the resulting access token against the deployed issuer's /jwks, checking issuer, audience, expiry, subject, principal type, tenant, roles, scope and assurance. Verify that operator consume and human consume requests are rejected. Local tests verify signatures against the JWKS handler; they do not constitute live issuance proof.

Negative verification requires the token endpoint's typed refusal: HTTP 400, invalid_profile_usage, feature scope for excess scope; HTTP 401 with feature Authorization for a predecessor secret. A timeout, 5xx, malformed response, invalid signature or JWKS failure is not proof of denial.

KeyCape owns issuance and client grants/disablement. OpenBao and the deployment operator own credential custody; approval-engine enforces its resource policy.