tegwick
041c0e7c3e
Some checks failed
ci / check (push) Failing after 4s
Thirteen challenges, five FATAL, all five conceded. Nothing had reached ground-game, which is the only reason this is a correction and not a retraction. The worst: `Reactive` was not "greedy with one preference changed". It differed in five, including SpendFreedom — ranked 95 unconditionally against greedy's `95 if gated else 0` — so the seat burned its Freedom token in round one of every game. A second change to the exact mechanism under study, and every number in CB-EV-0031 was measuring it. The pass claimed ADR-0018's one-varying-parameter discipline in its own workplan while violating it. GreedyPolicy::rank is now public and the policy delegates, overriding one match arm, so the control is structurally true. Withdrawn entirely: "H1-B suppresses DARVO in the attacker". Disabling H1-B under the corrected policy changes the arm count by exactly zero. The pass hedged the wrong variable — it disclaimed "the number 2" and defended "the direction", and the direction is what failed. The supporting inference was invalid anyway: final Stress cannot show who armed, because DarvoEnded resets the stage and REVERSE gives its owner -2. Corrected: criterion 1 was failed on the greedy column while the pass's own printed table showed 31-1000 arms in the other columns — the selective-column move, in the file that names it. "Peak Stress was 1" was a maximum over StressSet payloads, not held state (true: 2); the baseline game count was 1,600 not 3,200; and "a reckless policy plays identically to a careful one" is refuted by this repo's own rank-95 policy. Inert controls replaced, each verified red against the reviewer's own mutation: the baseline hash test compared two identically-constructed states (serde(skip) on variant left 57/57 green); the `unchanged:` test checked 3 of 7 entries and passed with SOLVE made illegal; H1-A's ordering and H1-B's OU-cancel path had no test at all. edition-check now covers catalog.yaml and rules_delta.yaml, whose digests CB-WP-0038 claimed and never recorded — the review found it and reported it unverified rather than absent, which was the right call. Still open: H1-B on the DARVO extra-Attack path is untested, regulation.rs still skips setup failures silently, and round-5 arms are counted though they can never act. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com> |
||
|---|---|---|
| .. | ||
| CB-EV-0001-game-kernel.md | ||
| CB-EV-0002-cost-accounting.md | ||
| CB-EV-0003-mechanical-work.md | ||
| CB-EV-0004-assertion-coverage.md | ||
| CB-EV-0005-instrument-the-table.md | ||
| CB-EV-0007-stage-0.md | ||
| CB-EV-0008-adaptive-gates.md | ||
| CB-EV-0009-inspectable-table.md | ||
| CB-EV-0010-render-port.md | ||
| CB-EV-0011-instrument-corrections.md | ||
| CB-EV-0012-execute-the-javascript.md | ||
| CB-EV-0013-the-inert-clauses.md | ||
| CB-EV-0014-the-drop-target.md | ||
| CB-EV-0015-legible-interaction.md | ||
| CB-EV-0016-the-browser-is-a-client.md | ||
| CB-EV-0017-budgets.md | ||
| CB-EV-0018-the-table-you-can-read.md | ||
| CB-EV-0019-import-the-edition.md | ||
| CB-EV-0020-solve-legality.md | ||
| CB-EV-0021-the-design-instrument.md | ||
| CB-EV-0022-collect-the-rulings.md | ||
| CB-EV-0023-the-table-you-can-watch.md | ||
| CB-EV-0024-could-we-have-won.md | ||
| CB-EV-0025-the-commentary-track.md | ||
| CB-EV-0026-the-table-you-sit-at.md | ||
| CB-EV-0027-the-tokens-on-the-table.md | ||
| CB-EV-0028-a-number-that-does-not-move.md | ||
| CB-EV-0029-the-fourteen-unread-files.md | ||
| CB-EV-0030-h1-measured.md | ||
| CB-EV-0031-a-seat-that-does-not-regulate.md | ||