tegwick
53bb65e7a6
Assistant: codex Assistant-Model: gpt-6-astra Assistant-Session: 01a0e241-8285-7a63-8c0c-51c9cb824dc3
2.6 KiB
0.1 preview acceptance review
2026-09-27 · Reviewer: Codex, author-model editorial and deterministic review. No independent human reviewer participated. Disposition: ready as a bounded research preview. This does not pass M1/M2/M3 or canonical admission.
| Requirement | Evidence and disposition |
|---|---|
| Core selection and source readiness | Source readiness and M1 review; eight core contracts qualified, empirical gates deferred |
| Ontology disposition | Ontology review; conditional proposals, separate preservation and resolution |
| Human reference paths | Start, two sequences, two scoped mappings and catalog; alternatives and unsupported needs explicit |
| Machine reference | Export checks candidate digests against the pinned Git corpus, input hashes, identities, vocabulary, endpoints, evidence paths and live residual references |
| Development navigation | Eight disclosed cases, including incompatible, underspecified and unsupported requests; editorial review only |
| Failure checks | Tests reject bad endpoints/types, missing evidence, empty conditions, duplicate selection, modified candidates, escaping paths and missing relation fields |
| Claim boundary | All seventeen records remain hypotheses; no empirical benefit, full-contract recurrence, accessibility conformance or production guarantees claimed |
Validation commands: make reference-test reference-check schema-test bench-test bench-plan evolution-check classification-check and git diff --check. The review
also checks relative file links in the changed and new Markdown reference surface.
The development cases are authored answers with deterministic reference checks;
there is no search engine, live model retrieval result or held-out score.
The manifest pins existing candidate contracts to 8cc7016 and hashes profile,
classification and vocabulary inputs. Packaging files are versioned by the commit
containing this review; the baseline revision does not contain this new guide.
Relative links resolve against the checkout, so use the corpus revision to recover
original candidate content after future changes.
Research residuals remain live under WP-0002 T03; WP-0003 T01–T04; WP-0004 T01–T03; and WP-0006 T03, with paths in the manifest. WP-0003 T04 explicitly records the source-review handoff origin. Finishing packaging closes none of those gates. No tag or external release publication is part of this review.