clay-borg/editions/ground-darvo-r0/Problems.csv at 19d2fae04f121fa1fbde4e97ccbe0b2b7c5c0621

tegwick 2da19a49b7 CB-WP-0021 T01/T02/T05: the engine plays its own data — AM-7 blocks

ADR-0011 decided it: vendor the CSV with a checked digest, read it with
a ~50-line reader, and let the hashes move.

The declaration's constraint was measured against the WRONG BUDGET. It
said a CSV crate costs 21,613 against AM-4a's 3,798 of headroom, '5.7x
over, settled by measurement'. But setup and problem_priorities are
cfg(scenarios) and are not in the shipped runtime at all, so AM-4a never
sees them. Against AM-4b, csv costs 17,651 against 19,742 -- it FITS,
with 2,091 to spare. It is refused anyway, on proportion: 89% of the
budget's remaining capacity to read 20 rows. The revisit condition is
stated (nested quoting, embedded newlines, multiple dialects).

GR-S01 now deals Surface + hidden 1..=k as ruled, with edition values and
suits. Measured: 6/9/12 available against thresholds 5/7/9 -- the game is
winnable at every seat count, which is what the maintainer could not do.
gd0001 is INVERTED, not deleted, and now also asserts the 6/9/12 so a
deal that is reachable for the wrong reason still fails.

Blast radius was scenario expectations, exactly as the ADR predicted: no
scenario pinned a hash and no bundle is committed. Six scenarios and two
unit tests updated, each with a note. gr-e01-threshold-unreachable-2p is
RENAMED to -reachable- and rewritten as the non-provisional import check
ground-game asked for by name. gr-e03's setup was restructured, not just
renumbered: with values 2,2,2 its personal-edge test would have tied
three ways and asserted nothing.

BLOCKING: AM-7 fails at median 0.845 against its 0.9 floor. Isolated
across three runs -- 3 problems + stand-in 0.97, 3 problems + edition
0.909, 4 problems + edition 0.845. State is BOUNDED (proven: identical
after 5k and 100k events), so this is not the unbounded-growth defect
AM-7 exists to catch; it is a bigger working set streaming a long log.
Whether AM-7's floor is still right for a larger aggregate is a spec
question and lowering it requires an ADR, so it is not being tuned here.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>

2026-08-04 00:47:56 +02:00

5.3 KiB

Raw Blame History

1	problem_id	scenario_id	visibility	hidden_priority	title	problem_text	required_solution	symbol_id	point_value	front_rules	reveal_effect	unresolved_effect	back_design_id
2	PRB_01_S	SCN_01	Surface	0	Deadline Missed	A promised result was not delivered when expected.	Repair	SYM_REPAIR	2	Resolve with Repair. Value: 2.	None in the core set.	No card-specific effect; it simply remains unsolved.	BACK_PROBLEM_SURFACE
3	PRB_01_1	SCN_01	Hidden	1	Unclear Ownership	Responsibility for the commitment and the work was never made explicit.	Clarify	SYM_CLARIFY	2	Resolve with Clarify. Value: 2.	None in the core set.	No card-specific effect; it simply remains unsolved.	BACK_PROBLEM
4	PRB_01_2	SCN_01	Hidden	2	Unspoken Overload	The work required more capacity than someone could safely or fairly provide.	Boundary	SYM_BOUNDARY	2	Resolve with Boundary. Value: 2.	None in the core set.	No card-specific effect; it simply remains unsolved.	BACK_PROBLEM
5	PRB_01_3	SCN_01	Hidden	3	Bad News Was Delayed	A warning was withheld until the remaining options became worse.	Repair	SYM_REPAIR	3	Resolve with Repair. Value: 3.	None in the core set.	No card-specific effect; it simply remains unsolved.	BACK_PROBLEM
6	PRB_01_4	SCN_01	Hidden	4	No Checkpoint Process	The group had no reliable moment for testing progress and changing course.	Change	SYM_CHANGE	3	Resolve with Change. Value: 3.	None in the core set.	No card-specific effect; it simply remains unsolved.	BACK_PROBLEM
7	PRB_02_S	SCN_02	Surface	0	Shared Task Left Undone	A recurring responsibility was not completed, and others absorbed the impact.	Repair	SYM_REPAIR	2	Resolve with Repair. Value: 2.	None in the core set.	No card-specific effect; it simply remains unsolved.	BACK_PROBLEM_SURFACE
8	PRB_02_1	SCN_02	Hidden	1	Different Standards	Players were using different definitions of complete, timely, or fair.	Clarify	SYM_CLARIFY	2	Resolve with Clarify. Value: 2.	None in the core set.	No card-specific effect; it simply remains unsolved.	BACK_PROBLEM
9	PRB_02_2	SCN_02	Hidden	2	Invisible Workload	Some contributions and constraints were not visible to the group.	Boundary	SYM_BOUNDARY	2	Resolve with Boundary. Value: 2.	None in the core set.	No card-specific effect; it simply remains unsolved.	BACK_PROBLEM
10	PRB_02_3	SCN_02	Hidden	3	Resentment Never Raised	Frustration accumulated without a direct request or acknowledgement.	Repair	SYM_REPAIR	3	Resolve with Repair. Value: 3.	None in the core set.	No card-specific effect; it simply remains unsolved.	BACK_PROBLEM
11	PRB_02_4	SCN_02	Hidden	4	No Ownership Routine	The group relied on goodwill instead of a dependable allocation method.	Change	SYM_CHANGE	3	Resolve with Change. Value: 3.	None in the core set.	No card-specific effect; it simply remains unsolved.	BACK_PROBLEM
12	PRB_03_S	SCN_03	Surface	0	Decision Announced as Settled	A group-affecting choice was presented as final before meaningful agreement.	Boundary	SYM_BOUNDARY	2	Resolve with Boundary. Value: 2.	None in the core set.	No card-specific effect; it simply remains unsolved.	BACK_PROBLEM_SURFACE
13	PRB_03_1	SCN_03	Hidden	1	Mandate Was Ambiguous	It was unclear who could decide, advise, consent, or veto.	Clarify	SYM_CLARIFY	2	Resolve with Clarify. Value: 2.	None in the core set.	No card-specific effect; it simply remains unsolved.	BACK_PROBLEM
14	PRB_03_2	SCN_03	Hidden	2	Contributions Were Dismissed	Relevant input was ignored or treated as less legitimate.	Repair	SYM_REPAIR	2	Resolve with Repair. Value: 2.	None in the core set.	No card-specific effect; it simply remains unsolved.	BACK_PROBLEM
15	PRB_03_3	SCN_03	Hidden	3	One Voice Spoke for Others	A player claimed authority to represent people who had not agreed.	Boundary	SYM_BOUNDARY	3	Resolve with Boundary. Value: 3.	None in the core set.	No card-specific effect; it simply remains unsolved.	BACK_PROBLEM
16	PRB_03_4	SCN_03	Hidden	4	No Decision Rule	The group had no shared method for turning discussion into a legitimate choice.	Change	SYM_CHANGE	3	Resolve with Change. Value: 3.	None in the core set.	No card-specific effect; it simply remains unsolved.	BACK_PROBLEM
17	PRB_04_S	SCN_04	Surface	0	Private Information Spread	Information moved beyond the circle in which it was originally shared.	Repair	SYM_REPAIR	2	Resolve with Repair. Value: 2.	None in the core set.	No card-specific effect; it simply remains unsolved.	BACK_PROBLEM_SURFACE
18	PRB_04_1	SCN_04	Hidden	1	Confidentiality Was Assumed	The players never made the scope of confidentiality explicit.	Clarify	SYM_CLARIFY	2	Resolve with Clarify. Value: 2.	None in the core set.	No card-specific effect; it simply remains unsolved.	BACK_PROBLEM
19	PRB_04_2	SCN_04	Hidden	2	Exposure Caused Harm	The sharing changed another player's safety, reputation, or freedom to choose.	Repair	SYM_REPAIR	2	Resolve with Repair. Value: 2.	None in the core set.	No card-specific effect; it simply remains unsolved.	BACK_PROBLEM
20	PRB_04_3	SCN_04	Hidden	3	Consent Boundary Was Ignored	A clear or reasonably expected limit on sharing was crossed.	Boundary	SYM_BOUNDARY	3	Resolve with Boundary. Value: 3.	None in the core set.	No card-specific effect; it simply remains unsolved.	BACK_PROBLEM
21	PRB_04_4	SCN_04	Hidden	4	No Sharing Protocol	The group lacked a repeatable rule for consent, need-to-know, and escalation.	Change	SYM_CHANGE	3	Resolve with Change. Value: 3.	None in the core set.	No card-specific effect; it simply remains unsolved.	BACK_PROBLEM

5.3 KiB Raw Blame History

5.3 KiB

Raw Blame History